Exactly. On Amazon (the review system I'm the most familiar with), if I find several one-star reviews that say some device was dead on arrival or a technical book was full of factual errors and typos, I'll definitely think twice before buying it, even if 90% of the reviews are five-star. I'm always grateful for the people who took the time to write honest and informative negative reviews.
Five star reviews tend to be fluff, one star reviews tend to be specific. I read them first, I look for dealbreakers. No amount of "I love it" can outvote "claims X but can't really X properly".