News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by graeme on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @07:58PM (#8205314)
This is a serious issue. On the one hand, our current system makes a one-star review far, far more consequential than it ought to be. If EVERYONE leaves positive reviews, than a single negative is very powerful.

On the other hand, leaving positive reviews out of politeness does a disservice to others. I hosted a couchsurfer once (a woman) who told me about her experience with another host. This guy had 10-20 positive reviews. And he was a total creep. Hit on her the entire time, asked her to sleep with him, and was intimidating. She left as soon as she could.

But she didn't leave a negative review! And clearly, other women must have had her experience, yet they said nothing either. This guy was left free to continue his horrible behavior.

I don't know the solution.

Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by tetrep on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @09:17PM (#8205503)
>I don't know the solution.

Trusted reviews. A user should be able to trust others, and to filter reviews based on that. Integration with social networking would allow for friends of friends trust as well. It would be far from perfect but it would better replicate the experience pre-internet of asking people around you, which works pretty well.

Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by wlievens on Thursday August 21, 2014 @03:08AM (#8206193)
But what are the odds of one out of a few dozen reviews to be written by your friend or even foaf?
Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by akkartik on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @09:29PM (#8205537)
The solution seems pretty clear: set a high bar before giving a one-star review, but be ruthless about giving it for behavior that's beyond the pale, like in your story.

Another way to phrase the heuristic might be: be lenient toward incompetence (including the bad turn in OP), but strict toward malice or unethical behavior.

Yet another phrasing: if the guy was CEO of a large company, say mozilla, should his behavior get him fired? If so, give him a one-star review. I find such thought experiments changing relative status to be quite useful.

Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by chrismcb on Thursday August 21, 2014 @03:34AM (#8206251)
Why should you be lenient towards incompetence. Would you want incompetent people working for you if you were any employer?
Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by graeme on Thursday August 21, 2014 @09:10AM (#8207149)
You could perhaps give a two, three or a four star review for various degrees of incompetence.

It depends on the review system. The article was addressed at five stars systems, where one star reviews do tend to have too low a bar for some, whereas others never leave negative reviews of any sort.

Other system are good/bad and there it's a harder choice whether to leave criticism. There's incompetence, and there's something that wasn't good but doesn't necessarily signify systemic incompetence. Leaving a review marked "bad" can't distinguish between those two, at least in the eyes of those that perceive it.

Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by vacri on Thursday August 21, 2014 @03:42AM (#8206269)
I don't know the solution.

Give accurate reviews, and provide context in a text format. If a system will fail because it has to meet an arbitrary quota (eg Uber's 4.6 stars), then that's a problem for the system to work out, not the person providing the review. The solution is simply to give dispassionate, honest reviews.

Re:Are One-Star Reviews for Assholes? by robryan on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @09:21PM (#8205517)
Kind of like eBay buyer reviews. They are completely useless as the only person that will likely ever give a bad review is a small seller that has been completely jerked around and doesn't at all rely on ebay for income.