News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by mhurron on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:14PM (#8203250)
Then why post anything at all?
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by byerley on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:24PM (#8203316)
Because it's a poorly written article and the media on this issue is in a really silly place right now, but no one sane wants to deal with the hysteria currently associated with mentioning a burger chain so it's hard to construct well-reasoned yet diplomatic criticism.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by A_COMPUTER on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:41PM (#8203412)
I want to take a moment to talk about a woman in video games. She made a really great game, well some people don't call them games, but it was a text adventure game. A quite well made one. Many people didn't realize how effectively you could leverage the medium to make such an emotionally evocative piece of, dare I say it, art.

I am of course talking about Emily Short. In the year 2000 or thereabouts, she made a short interactive fiction story called "Galatea." ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galatea_%28video_game%29 ) I highly suggest trying it out.

I think it's sad how fourteen years later, similar to the devolution of FPS's from Quake to Call of Duty, some new text adventures may have gained a much wider audience and are praised to high heaven but are clearly inferior artistically and in design.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by lizzard on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @02:26PM (#8203692)
Emily Short is a truly great game author, theorist, designer, and contributor to Inform7! She has won several awards for her work. I hope no one thinks of her as "forgotten".
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by makeset on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @02:19PM (#8203645)
What do you mean by "devolution from Quake to Call of Duty"? I am honestly curious, as I haven't played either (motion sickness; no FPS for me).
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by Crito on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @06:41PM (#8205066)
I don't know what he means, but I can give my own perspective (primarily ex-gamer, used to play a lot of Q3A, Doom, and similar):

FPS games used to have very simple orthogonal game mechanics. Large amounts of complexity would arise from those small lists of simple game mechanics. A 'board game equivalent' to this concept might be Go (or if we are being less flattering to the video game industry, Draughts/Checkers). This orthogonality was best showcased in weapon design; you'd often have less than 10 guns, which each behaved in completely different ways and were best used in completely different situations.

  Q3A examples:
    gauntlet: the only melee weapon
    machine gun: hitscan, accurate, fast rate of fire, low damage.
                 typically available on spawn.
    shotgun: hitscan, inaccurate, slow rate of fire, large damage when close.
             must be picked up.
    railgun: hitscan, accurate, slow rate of fire, devastating damage.
             must be picked up.
    lightning gun: not-quite-hitscan beam, medium-short range, high damage.
                   must be picked up.
    etc...
Modern games, typically aiming for some perverse sense of "realism", typically lack this sort of weapon orthogonality. You get typically get the basic categories of "assault rifle", "sniper rifle", "handgun", "submachine gun", and "something that shoots explosives", which is all fine and good, except each of those categories has half a dozen or more variations that have very boring differences. Like 6 pistols that only differ in clip size or damage (with one or two clearly being the dominant weapons in all situations). For a concrete example of a game that I think suffers from this: Watch_Dogs. 10 different handguns, but the only one that it ever makes sense to use is the handgun that you start the game with (accurate, silenced, and semi-automatic. yeah there are the automatic handguns, but why would you use them when you could just use one of the automatic rifles? The game gives you absolutely no reason to care about the other handguns).

That's just weapons. I have observed similar trends across nearly all other game mechanics in modern shooters. It is like game developers forgot how to create complexity from a small list of simple mechanics and instead just pack games full of shallow features.

When you play or watch a game, try the following: Imagine that all the models and textures were swapped out with generic low-poly abstract placeholders. All handguns are small thin blue boxes, rifles are all long thin teal boxes, etc. Does the game still play well? If it is Quake or Doom, then the game plays exactly the same as it did before. If it is a modern game, then chances are several pointless redundancies become obvious and several previously "neat" game mechanics become obviously shallow. They have several "different" game mechanics that are different from each other only in the model, texture, or animation used.

Mario-Party-esque "Push X to perform [every damn action in the game]" stuff is another biggie for me. Incredibly lazy stuff which apparently appeals to modern gamers.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by byerley on Thursday August 21, 2014 @10:13AM (#8207403)
Thanks for the recommendation btw, enjoyed it very much.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by recursive on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:28PM (#8203335)
> hysteria currently associated with mentioning a burger chain

The what now?

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by SheepSlapper on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:28PM (#8203332)
Yup. I know exactly what he means, but we don't have to explicitly say it and open that whole can of worms. I think it's best to grab some popcorn and watch from the sidelines, not actively participate in the silliness.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:22PM (#8203304)
To point out that the stifling of politically-incorrect speech and speech critical of certain topics has a chilling effect.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by CJefferson on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:27PM (#8203330)
How is someone writing an article about a very little discussed topic, compared to the huge number of articles and books about make game developers, stifling?
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by lobotryas on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:49PM (#8203473)
You have it the other way around. Tomp is saying that indiscriminately shutting down any criticism of this topic is having a chilling effect on discourse.

I agree. Can you imagine anyone daring to post a negative opinion about this article? They'd be verbally assaulted, down voted and shadow-banned in minutes.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @01:44PM (#8203439)
I wasn't talking about the article being stifling, rather the discussion (as witnessed by the downvotes). Can you list some of the articles/books about specifically male game developers? I haven't seen any yet (though I must admit that I rarely read anything about gaming, except technically oriented articles).
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by CJefferson on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @05:56PM (#8204894)
There are huge numbers of articles and books which exclusively discuss male game developers, almost every one I've ever read.

Did any of them say "This article will only be about men"? No. I'm not clear of your point -- do you wish all articles which only discuss men were labelled as such?

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Thursday August 21, 2014 @04:27AM (#8206416)
My point exactly; there are no articles saying "this article will only be about men" like this one is about women. Instead, they are saying "this article will be about great games" or "shitty games" or such. That's why I perceive this article as sexist.
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tptacek on Thursday August 21, 2014 @03:49PM (#8209207)
That's because you're using a term you don't fully understand. Singling out men and women for gender-neutral praise ("great women in video games" or "great women in badminton" or whatever) isn't sexist.

"Sexist" is a normative term. It describes an "ought". Specifically: sexism points out instances where we "ought not" stereotype genders. So it would be sexist to point out that women as a class are inferior or superior at video game development. This post does neither of these things.

The term you're flailing around for is "gender biased". "Gender bias" is a descriptive term. It describes an "is". This post "is" about highlighting the achievements of women in the industry. It uses gender as a criteria for inclusion.

By itself, gender bias leaves you with too many unknowns to solve the system for a normative result. You can add intent and circumstances (for instance) to solve it for impact. If you think the intent of this article is to suggest that women are superior to men, you'll sound like a crazy person. If you suggest that the circumstances of gender balance in our industry are such that women's achievements are nonnotable, you'll sound like your head is in the sand. But you haven't even done either of those two things; you've got x, y, and z, one equation, and have just decided to leave y and z out and declare the system solved.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by kasey_junk on Thursday August 21, 2014 @10:53PM (#8210698)
One example of this I've used in the past is a maternity ward. This is very clearly a health facility with a high level of gender bias. It is not sexist in the least though.

I haven't figured out a good example of something that is sexist that doesn't display gender bias though...

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Friday August 22, 2014 @01:06PM (#8212923)
> Singling out men and women for gender-neutral praise isn't sexist.

I agree. However, this isn't a Wikipedia article (which should usually be accompanied by a similar article about the opposite sex). And this article has some issues (IMO) that a Wikipedia article wouldn't have; I won't list them, as I said in my first comment, but @pervycreeper list some of the issues he sees.

> The term you're flailing around for is "gender biased".

Possibly. However, in my mind "sexism" (along with every other "-ism") is defined as any (irrelevant) discrimination, including positive discrimination. Therefore, I perceive the current "more women in CS" craze (nor the general "more people in CS" trend) as inappropriate/(unfairly) biased/-ism. Of course, we might argue whether it's irrelevant or not; personally, I was brought up in a different society where everyone had to work, my mother was the technical person in the family, and if anything, I was discouraged from spending too much time behind the computer, so I'm convinced that in my country, in my generation, computer skills are the result of means (computers were much more expensive back then) and interest, and not gender at all; if I were brought up in the US, I might have a different view on sexism in CS.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tptacek on Friday August 22, 2014 @02:38PM (#8213348)
Well, what's in your mind is interesting, I guess, but it has nothing to do with how the world works.

The reality is: people who talk about "reverse sexism" like this are, almost as a rule, trying to minimize discussion of sexism against women. I'm now discriminating against you based on that statement, but it's OK, because that discrimination isn't irrelevant: there's a search bar at the bottom of the page, and it's really easy to use it to see where you stand on this issue.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Wednesday August 27, 2014 @08:05AM (#8231706)
> but it has nothing to do with how the world works.

Possibly. But as they say, "be the change you want to see in the world".

> people who talk about "reverse sexism" like this are, almost as a rule, trying to minimize discussion of sexism against women

Well, there is sexism and there is "sexism". If we're talking about things like forced marriage (more specifically, older men marrying underage women), FGM, human trafficking/sex tourism, violent rape, etc., I'm all for it. Of course, these topics are rarely discussed, because there is no discussion necessary - pretty much all people agree that they are awful, and that they should be solved.

On the other hand, if we're talking about things like GitHub's meritocracy rug, "the patriarchy", that the female CEOs are paid less than male CEOs, that there should be more women/people in CS, or domestic violence against women, then I'll be pointing out a few things; (1) these topics are not really deserving of the attention they're getting (poor millionaire CEOs; why don't we talk about the homeless people instead), (2) they are sexist (why not talk about domestic violence in general - recent studies suggest that there is a huge number of male victims as well, and no support systems for them), (3) they often have a hidden agenda (noone wanted to be a programmer before geeks became cool and started earning a lot of money). IMO, these are all very valid arguments, but because they are comments about sensitive topics, they get downvoted.

Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by CJefferson on Friday August 22, 2014 @08:04AM (#8211709)
If an article doesn't say it will only be about men, but is then only about men, is it sexist? (I don't really have a firm result here, certainly some articles just happen to be about men, and others which should mention men).
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by tomp on Friday August 22, 2014 @12:34PM (#8212798)
Depends on what's in it; an article about Nobel laureates that doesn't mention Marie Curie, or an article about the history of CS that doesn't mention Lovelace, Hopper or Liskov probably is. However, if history in a particular subject was made mostly by men, it's totally appropriate for an article about that history to mention only men. I don't know enough about history of gaming to judge this article on that merit (personally, I would only list 3 notable games programmers: Newell, Sweeney, Carmack, and a dozen or so games).
Re:Underappreciated Female Video Game Pioneers by recursive on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @03:31PM (#8204095)
Please don't interpret my downvotes as anything other than a chilling effect on nonsensical comments.