News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Do We Say “Big Red Barn,” But “Red Big Barn” Sounds W... by jameshart on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @12:35PM (#8198274)
I'd considered it when I had assumed it was a somewhat irregular pattern, but as I say, it turns out there is a rule and that isn't it.

You're right that '-ed' suffixes prevent '-er'/'-est' being appended even if they don't add a second syllable to their root, though in most cases '-ed' makes a word multisyllabic so forces it down the 'most' route. 'bored' or, as you say, 'rouged' are monosyllabic exceptions, though. And that's in spite of there being no awkward sound created - you could certainly say 'boreder' (it's pronounced just like 'border' or 'boarder'), but it's not a word. English is weird.

But with 'open', I don't see your point. It's interesting, in fact, that even though the word 'opener' is a valid word, in the context of a 'can opener', say, it is not a valid comparative for open. It is wrong to say 'The light through the large window makes this room much opener than that one' - you should say it makes it 'much more open' instead. But you could say it made it 'much brighter'.

Re:Why Do We Say “Big Red Barn,” But “Red Big Barn” Sounds W... by logfromblammo on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @11:00AM (#8202570)
Opener was an example of a potentially ambiguous word. That may be why the superlative -er is not allowed. The noun-forming -er prevails over the adjective-forming -er.
Re:Why Do We Say “Big Red Barn,” But “Red Big Barn” Sounds W... by jameshart on Wednesday August 20, 2014 @11:21AM (#8202693)
Nope, open takes 'more' because it's bisyllabic, not because it avoids a collision with the noun 'opener'. Lighter, warmer, cooler... all common enough verb-based nouns that collide with comparatives and don't take 'more' because they're monosyllables.
Re:Why Do We Say “Big Red Barn,” But “Red Big Barn” Sounds W... by logfromblammo on Thursday August 21, 2014 @01:22PM (#8208462)
Your simpler explanation is certainly cleverer than mine, by far. My narrower criterion obviously has several counterexamples, so I should probably be quieter about it until I can gather more supporting evidence.

English is complicated. Let's not pretend that we know about some intentionally engineered structure in it when we're really just noticing patterns and correlations.