News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by Spooky23 on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:13PM (#8194392)
I agree it was a biased statement, but the key issue is that if you roll out soldiers to address a civil disturbance, you need to figure out what they are going to do.

If they are there to prevent escalation, they need to take the abuse hurled at them and suck it up.

Saying "We come in peace and respect you, stand by while we crack your skull open with a truncheon" doesn't exempt your conduct. If standard operating procedure calls for escalation from skull-cracking to rifle fire into a crowd to machine gunning of the crowd, we have a problem.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by justizin on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:26PM (#8194461)
"if you roll out soldiers to address a civil disturbance, you need to figure out what they are going to do."

One of the interesting things I learned participating in a number of protests in recent years surrounded by veterans is that they were shocked at the local PD's willingness to violate basic human rights in ways that they'd never have been allowed in the Army / Marines / etc..

One of the concerns I discussed with a friend this weekend regarding the current / recent situation in Ferguson is that police with military equipment are doing things that are simply not acceptable for soldiers at war, such as outright pointing their weapons into a crowd in order to get people's attention, as well as the unchecked use of teargas which I also saw in Oakland.

I don't look forward to encountering any group of soldiers in a demonstration, nor do I doubt the Army has policies that are frightening, but one of the most frightening things about the militarization of police is that police are civilians who do not answer to the Uniform Code of Military Justice, nor do they require proper training on how to interact with the public as military. Many of them are vets, but not all of them had such duties while in the service.

This is why you often hear the perception that these police are 'dressed up to play soldier' because as horrifying as it is that a city would send soldiers in to repress its' citizens, it's an order of magnitude worse because they aren't trained to have any restraint and the protest they are policing is _directly_ against them and their presence in the area.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by click170 on Monday August 18, 2014 @05:21PM (#8194758)
John Oliver touched on this in his recent segment.

The Army, is given training in Escalation Of Force. The police, who are being given all these toys because terrorists and drugs, do not have that training.

This is why you hear about the police shooting and killing unarmed civilians, deploying teargas in residential areas, and walking around pointing their weapons at people instead of the ground.

Frankly they shouldn't have that gear at all, but if you're going to give it to them at least train them properly with it first.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by justizin on Monday August 18, 2014 @07:00PM (#8195159)
"Frankly they shouldn't have that gear at all, but if you're going to give it to them at least train them properly with it first."

Absolutely 1000% what I was trying to get across.

I don't want to see the national guard in my neighborhood, but I would rather see them than the Alameda County Sheriffs or CHP armed with the national guard's equipment.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by Spooky23 on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:53PM (#8195841)
The horrifying part is that the police leadership is willing to throw the policemen into the breach, overarmed to a degree that just begs for escalation.

It's hard to fault the individual policemen -- when someone starts tossing molotov cocktails, your view of reasonable force is going to be different.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by rdtsc on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:58PM (#8194642)
Just like in any large institution, there are written explicit rules and there are unwritten rules. Quite often unwritten rules are the opposite of explicit written rules.

The explicit rules are there to provide a background of what is acceptable in PR-speak. The unwritten ones have to be inferred. For example when they say:

"Oh protesters often try to provoke us so we commit violence. And well we are nice little soldiers, and we want to abide by the Constitution"

You can read that literally or you can read that as an advice -- make sure to plant undercover people in the crowd of protesters. Who will initiate violent and provocative actions, so that you can respond properly and squash the protest.

And that is exactly what is done often.

In fact most successful navigators in the bureaucracy who climb to the top, have a very good instinct of understanding these unwritten rules.

P.S. Another, made up and hyperbolic example could be say during the Vietnam War. There could have been a rule written "Make sure to count the number of captured Viet Cong when you disembark from the helicopter. And make sure to never to harshly interrogate them during transport and threaten to throw them overboard". See a nice rule of what not to do. Except that is also a rule-book for those that understand things a little deeper of exactly what to do.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by bcoates on Monday August 18, 2014 @06:01PM (#8194957)
It's not like this is a hypothetical -- the US military is deployed all over the world, and routinely faces protesters. Do these confrontations result in violence more often than, for example, ones involving US domestic police forces?
Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by rdtsc on Monday August 18, 2014 @08:49PM (#8195517)
> Do these confrontations result in violence more often than, for example, ones involving US domestic police forces?

Well if domestic police force could use drone to blast away protesters they would rather do that then get down and dirty. But alas they actually have put on their tactical vests and drive the APC to the scene...

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by mpyne on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:24PM (#8195756)
The U.S. Army doesn't simply use drones to blast away protestors though, so I'm not sure what that has to do with anything.

There have been many soldiers who have died because in their race to follow proper "Escalation of Force" procedures, the other guy blew them up or shot them before they could get to the point where the soldier was allowed to use deadly force in self-defense.

When the U.S. Army finally went to New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, Gen. Honoré told his subordinates that he would get the paratroopers serving under him shot, before he would allow soldiers to walk around with body armor, weapons un-slung, or to open fire at anybody. They were quite successful in helping to restore order, and they didn't have to open fire on anybody; this was contrasted with police efforts beforehand, which had been limited to "stay in your homes".

So go ahead and talk about Vietnam all you want. You should probably throw in Kent State too! But this is 2014, and the Army should be evaluated on what it's doing today and into the future.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by rdtsc on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @12:30AM (#8196029)
> The U.S. Army doesn't simply use drones to blast away protestors though,

What does it do? How many large protests have there been in Afghanistan or Iraq? I don't anything large happening there. You know why. Because anyone trying to organize protests in a war zone get killed "enemy combatants".

> the other guy blew them up or shot them before they could get to the point where the soldier was allowed to use deadly force in self-defense.

Ok, let's talk modern day if you don't like Vietnam. What the fuck was a US soldier doing in Iraq to start with? Was there a draft? I don't recall there being one.

If Iraqi Army was in the streets of New York you bet you'll see their soldiers getting below up to bits with IEDs just as much even if not more.

> Gen. Honoré told his subordinates that he would get the paratroopers serving under him shot,

So Gen. knows how to spew propaganda. Hell, he wouldn't be a good general if he didn't.

> So go ahead and talk about Vietnam all you want.

I will. It provides a solid historical basis. We can go further back too.

> the Army should be evaluated on what it's doing today and into the future.

What is it doing today? Have the found any WMDs yet? They sure spent a lot of time, money and lives looking. If that doesn't spell "failure" I don't know what does. It is both economic, moral, political and social.

Let's chat some more. How about that Abu Ghraib? What was that all about. A few bad apples. How about the apples down in Cuba. Also a few bad apples.

What happened in Mahmudiah? Raping children. Bad apples again. What the fuck where they doing there to start with.

There is more. But I just get angry writing about it. So I think I'll stop here.

I was just being nice talking about Vietnam. But ok if you want to talk about recent event, fine let's talk about.

Re:U.S. Army Techniques Publication 3-39.33: Civil Disturbances by mpyne on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @06:47PM (#8200257)
> What the fuck was a US soldier doing in Iraq to start with? Was there a draft? I don't recall there being one.

A draft has nothing at all to do with whether the invasion in 2003 was a legal use of armed force or not, under U.S. domestic law or international law. If that invasion was illegal without the draft, then it was also illegal with a draft. Being a conscript doesn't make your participation in an otherwise illegal invasion magically legal.

But. Even if you disagree (as I do) with the justification for invading in Iraq in 2003, there are and were plenty of legitimate reasons for U.S. forces to be there to restore security after the U.S. fucked everything up.

In fact, the current government of Iraq and the Kurdish pesh merge invited the U.S. back in to conduct air strikes to beat back ISIS (who prominently came to power after the U.S. military left...), much to the acclaim of practically the entire world, including the U.N., including Pope Francis, including Iraqis themselves. I'll bet even Iran was happy.

But that U.S. intervention was just as legal as the U.S. presence in 2005. You can't have your cake and eat it too, man.

> So Gen. knows how to spew propaganda. Hell, he wouldn't be a good general if he didn't.

It wasn't just the General. The Democratic mayor of New Orleans was quite complimentary as well: http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/09/02/honore.profile/

But either way, no offense but your idea that an Army General (or soldier in general) is simply locked into being a bloodthirsty monster by virtue of the system they operate in is just as crazy as the idea that being a black single mother must make you a welfare queen, or that being a gay homosexual must mean that you like home decorating and keep up with fashion.

> Have the found any WMDs yet?

The Army never said there was WMDs to find, so what's that have to do with anything.

> How about that Abu Ghraib?

Reported to the world by the Army? That Abu Ghraib? I mean, if you want to bash on the Army, you should bash on the Army for refusing to promote the Major General who investigated the conditions at Abu Ghraib after it was leaked to the world and came back with a report damning of the entire setup of the U.S. presence at the prison. http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/06/25/the-generals-re...

There's plenty of bad apples, alright, but they were wearing stars on their collars, and suits and ties, and included officers and civilians. Not just generals, but Rumsfeld, and Congress too. Should we disband Congress then? Install a benevolent dictator?

Gen. Taguba points it out best himself: "From the moment a soldier enlists, we inculcate loyalty, duty, honor, integrity, and selfless service. And yet when we get to the senior-officer level we forget those values...".

OK, so there are a bunch of senior officer shit bags... does that make integrity, service, honor and duty bad things? No, it doesn't, and in any event soldiers get immersed in those values to a far greater degree than local and state police forces.

It was those same values about sacrifice and integrity that led a junior enlisted soldier to inform the world about the Mahmuydiah atrocity you pointed out. That wasn't caught by a human rights activist, it was caught and reported by a soldier.

So if your viewpoint is that an entire institution must be put to death for the crimes of its members I'm going to have to disagree. Should all libertarians have to answer for the slayings contracted by DPR? Should all Socialists have to answer for Stalin and Mao?