Re:Existence does not imply correlation
by tptacek on Monday August 18, 2014 @03:53PM
(#8194266)
Here's why a reasonable reader might come to the conclusion that this is not in fact a post about correlation, but rather a device for making a drive-by dig at Sam Altman's post:
* The Redis example is forced. Here's why: most engineers faced with that problem would, sooner rather than later, collect stats about the nodes and immediately observe that the root cause was an overloaded server. As the post admits, the cause was immediately obvious. No statistical reasoning was required, and, in fact, this reader doubts that statistics played too much of a role in Stucchio's own diagnosis. (Whether it actually did or didn't isn't material to my point.)
* The insight being provided about correlation is extremely simplistic. Essentially, it communicates in two graphs the definition of correlation. That might make sense if the post was written in a fashion that tried to communicate the fundamental idea of correlation to someone with literally no acquaintance to the term. But it's not; despite having subheds about what "is" and "isn't" correlation, the writing style more clearly signifies that the author is trying to debunk a mistaken idea about what the term is, implying that its readers are already somewhat acquainted with the idea. Or, put more simply: the fundamental idea the post tries to communicate could have been conveyed in two simple sentences. (Glass houses about my own writing style: duly noted).
* The transition from technical discussion to Sam Altman is abrupt. More importantly, the Altman subject has much more valence than the point about diagnosing Redis failures. Thought experiment: chop everything in this article after Redis out, and imagine it was posted not by Chris but by some random account. Would anyone pay attention to this post?
Unfortunately, the post doesn't have much insight to offer about Altman's post. It's framed Altman in a manner incompatible with Altman's post --- suggesting, contrary to reality, that Altman was trying to present a complete empirical argument about gender disparities in technology. It then tries to beat Altman over the head with that framing. Altman emerges unscathed, because the author is swinging at his shadow, not him.
* The Redis example is forced. Here's why: most engineers faced with that problem would, sooner rather than later, collect stats about the nodes and immediately observe that the root cause was an overloaded server. As the post admits, the cause was immediately obvious. No statistical reasoning was required, and, in fact, this reader doubts that statistics played too much of a role in Stucchio's own diagnosis. (Whether it actually did or didn't isn't material to my point.)
* The insight being provided about correlation is extremely simplistic. Essentially, it communicates in two graphs the definition of correlation. That might make sense if the post was written in a fashion that tried to communicate the fundamental idea of correlation to someone with literally no acquaintance to the term. But it's not; despite having subheds about what "is" and "isn't" correlation, the writing style more clearly signifies that the author is trying to debunk a mistaken idea about what the term is, implying that its readers are already somewhat acquainted with the idea. Or, put more simply: the fundamental idea the post tries to communicate could have been conveyed in two simple sentences. (Glass houses about my own writing style: duly noted).
* The transition from technical discussion to Sam Altman is abrupt. More importantly, the Altman subject has much more valence than the point about diagnosing Redis failures. Thought experiment: chop everything in this article after Redis out, and imagine it was posted not by Chris but by some random account. Would anyone pay attention to this post?
Unfortunately, the post doesn't have much insight to offer about Altman's post. It's framed Altman in a manner incompatible with Altman's post --- suggesting, contrary to reality, that Altman was trying to present a complete empirical argument about gender disparities in technology. It then tries to beat Altman over the head with that framing. Altman emerges unscathed, because the author is swinging at his shadow, not him.