That's not exactly what I'd say. :) Tornado without twisted is simpler than tornado with twisted, because you can't ignore the huge system you'd otherwise be able to avoid.
Edit to remove mild flame.
It's the same reason smart companies are compelled to contribute changes to open source projects. That's a lot of maintenance you get for free.
That's why friendfeed didn't do their own python implementation on top of their own posix operating system to make sure they had a firm grasp on all the parts. A working and well-tested component is almost always better than writing a new one from scratch that you have to deal with yourself.
I suppose I'm just letting you know how you can better serve my personal needs next time you invent something great. :)
Or, looking at it another way, you removed Tornado's simple 1400-line core, and replaced it with a 150,000-line dependency.
(Yes, I know that Tornado On Twisted doesn't depend on the entire Twisted framework. But the port does involve a lot more code in total than the original.)
I think this is a bit misleading. The twisted port involved removing almost 1,400 lines of code and didn't change the tornado API. That is, tornado is not more simple without twisted.
I do understand the value of being able to read all of the code quickly, but there are other turtles below these. For me, it's very valuable to know that the part upon which I'm building is a well-tested codebase whose semantics I understand, and for which I can write tests when things begin to violate my understanding.
If tornado is used in more applications, it will have to grow in complexity to meet the needs of those applications. I see tornado as having two faces. The web portions can certainly continue to grow, but the network IO handing just means that people will have to port over things that already exist within twisted, and expand it in complexity (such as the kqueue work that is in progress) to handle more low-level stuff.
At some point, you can't just easily sit down and read all of it (at least, not any more easily than you can with twisted).