News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US plans to require inter-vehicle communication technolog... by ams6110 on Monday August 18, 2014 @02:47PM (#8193914)
I think if you can't pay enough attention to avoid turning across oncoming traffic, you shouldn't be driving, warning gizmos or no.
Re:US plans to require inter-vehicle communication technolog... by anigbrowl on Monday August 18, 2014 @03:08PM (#8194042)
Road design can also have a lot to do with it. There's a rather dangerous intersection close to my house, where there's a serious right-angle collision about every 2 months on average (over a >2 year observation period). It's close to a freeway on-ramp (so you get people who are in a hurry), visibility is poor in some directions due to large trees and bus shelters, and you have a 2 lane street crossing a 6 lane one (zoning boundary that's also a transit artery).
Re:US plans to require inter-vehicle communication technolog... by phkahler on Monday August 18, 2014 @03:16PM (#8194077)
>> Road design...

I couldn't agree more. We have roads set up in grid, forcing intersections every mile. Not only is this a huge safety issue, the stopping is where a large part of fuel goes and is where half the time spent commuting goes. The urban drive cycle has an average speed of just under 20mph due to all the stopping.

Re:US plans to require inter-vehicle communication technolog... by Someone1234 on Monday August 18, 2014 @02:55PM (#8193967)
That's a very anti-safety attitude. If your assumption of safety comes from the concept that everyone should be perfect all of the time then it is deeply flawed.

Even pilots need systems like ACAS to avoid collisions, and that is on top of on-board radar, significant training, and ATC who are there to make sure such things never occur. Yet how many times has there been a collision averted by ACAS since its introduction? Dozens? Hundreds? Who knows (FAA maybe?). A lot.

If our attitude to driving was more similar to our attitude to airline safety then our roads would be significantly safer today. In the airline industry it is all about continuous improvement and learning from even minor accidents, on the roads we just ignore such things as a "regular problem we have to put up with."

Re:US plans to require inter-vehicle communication technolog... by VLM on Monday August 18, 2014 @04:01PM (#8194317)
Its possible to turn the argument around to "If your assumption of safety comes from the concept that all safety equipment should be perfect all of the time"

Given the inherent immense liability problem, it seems almost impossible to release this as a product without some kind of government blanket immunity to criminal/civil prosecution, otherwise the mfgr will be dragged into every legal dispute tangentially involving the car and a crash. Therefore with no motivation to produce a perfect product, perfect products will not be released.

The end result will be drivers with a careless attitude because they purchased something to take responsibility, causing the overall accident / death rate to increase, despite society as a whole spending more money. I'm not seeing much net good coming out of this.