While doctors do typically go to school for a more 'general' understanding of any given disease, they still have a great more background on the subject than the average person, which probably helps them differentiate (to an extent) between the signal and noise of any given research paper that someone researching may come across.
The same could very much be said about software. To a non-technical person, searching about 'why you should use Windows vs Mac' could be pretty fruitless. Sure, there's plenty of information available, and numbers can easily support one or the other, but do you actually know what those numbers represent?
Now, I'm not saying that patients shouldn't be able to see their records, nor that they shouldn't spend the time learning about any conditions they may have (though I won't claim that I have), but I don't think we should discredit the knowledge that your average doctor has about your health.
Distrust of your healthcare provider isn't exactly healthy either. And again, as to your last point, can you elaborate? I'm assuming your referencing something to do with depression and obesity, as you mentioned in your original comment, but you haven't really mentioned what it is they're failing at.
If you distrust your healthcare provider, find a new one. But if your healthcare provider does respect you and your needs, isn't willing to answer your questions, then I also think you should find a new one.
And, as I've said elsewhere, I am not discrediting their knowledge. I'm recognizing that their knowledge, like any person's, is bounded. They have to care about hundreds of patients with hundreds of conditions. You have the opportunity to care about yourself. Take it.
>>existential fear resulting from the balance of power between patient and doctor than anything else
It's the most elemental fear of all, I think. It's the fear of one's own mortality. Would the doctor-patient relationship be so fraught otherwise?
While I feel comfortable with my knowledge in certain areas[1], I definitely don't have the breadth of knowledge a doctor does (and the more specialized the doctor, the more true that is). But even in that situation, after a visit to the doctor, it's time to hit the books and understand what is really going on, what the current state of research is, and what options exist.
1. Yes, I do believe there are certain, narrow areas where I am more knowledgable than the average doctor, but these are areas that are, unfortunately, not covered well in medical school. I consider it unfortunate because they are also areas (most likely) underlying much of the chronic illness in the US and other Western countries.