Re:An Iron Curtain Has Descended Upon Psychopharmacology
by davorak on Sunday August 17, 2014 @10:58AM
(#8189504)
I agree with TeMPOraL, the first sentence sets up the example:
> Imagine if a chemist told you offhandedly that the Russians had different chemical elements than we did.
Make it clear that different elements being used in Russia is a hypothetical. He then uses it to show the absurd state of the state of psychopharmacology.
Re:An Iron Curtain Has Descended Upon Psychopharmacology
by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 17, 2014 @10:54AM
(#8189495)
Look at the first sentence of the post. Or the beginning of the paragraph you just quoted. Elements being different in different countries is clearly marked as an absurd example.
Re:An Iron Curtain Has Descended Upon Psychopharmacology
by ajb on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:53AM
(#8189628)
Okay, I agree, he's being sarcastic. Sorry, I'm obviously too tired to contribute to this discussion.
Re:An Iron Curtain Has Descended Upon Psychopharmacology
by chemunc on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:36PM
(#8189725)
It's things like this that point out that the author a) can't write effectively and b) doesn't know anything about pharmacology/medicinal chemistry. Why are people going nuts about an article written about a very advanced subject that's written by a non-expert?
Re:An Iron Curtain Has Descended Upon Psychopharmacology
by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:16PM
(#8189988)
If someone working at a hospital, doing psychiatry for a living and known for reading tons of research papers is a "non-expert" then I don't know who to read anymore. By this standard you shouldn't listen to anyone here about anything related to programming or startups.
But as far as I can tell this is exactly the state of modern psychopharmacology."
It's not obvious whether the author really thinks that the Russians have found some new elements, or is just using the term 'element' to mean 'chemical', but either is erroneous.