Re:Inside The Making Of The New “Dungeons and Dragons”
by tormeh on Sunday August 17, 2014 @08:54AM
(#8189287)
Pen and paper can never beat computer games at combat mechanics because the rules have to be human-friendly to compute. Pen and paper lives and dies with storytelling, which is why I prefer simple rules a la World of Darkness (apparently mages are really complicated, though).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Inside The Making Of The New “Dungeons and Dragons”
by Retric on Sunday August 17, 2014 @10:18AM
(#8189411)
This 1000 times this. You can condense the rules for a fun RPG game down to a single piece of paper. These companies only make money selling rule books so they want something more complex which does not necessarily mean fun.
Re:Inside The Making Of The New “Dungeons and Dragons”
by tormeh on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:08AM
(#8189521)
Well, they could always sell monster manuals and pre-canned stories. City maps and politics. Those are the exciting parts, anyway.
Re:Inside The Making Of The New “Dungeons and Dragons”
by Retric on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:41AM
(#8189597)
Option A, monsters use the players class system.
Option B, monsters use a separate system, need to be balanced externally and become part of a large rule system...
City maps and politics might work, but pre canned campaigns never seem to sell well because building that stuff is generally considered a fun part of being a DM.
That said, I actually found D&D/white wolf source books and monster manuals etc a fun read on their own.