News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by mindcrime on Friday August 15, 2014 @07:56PM (#8184934)
The most interesting bit of the article, to me, is this:

“Encouraging managers not to rely entirely on the automated software is the best thing they can do. But I’m doubtful of how many managers will actually do it,” she said, because of the wide variation in how managers at different stores treat their employees.

Why? Because it gets to the point that a company may, on the whole be trying to do the right thing, and may have progressive policies, etc., but - at the end of the day - it is individual middle managers who most directly impact the conditions that workers experience.

I doubt this point will resonate with the left'ish wing folks who consider all business owners evil, blab about "capitalist oppressors" and want a wholesale adoption of socialist (or psuedo-socialist) policies, but this is the truth. Companies are not inherently evil, and companies can - and do - choose to try to do right by their employees... but enforcing consistent application of a policy related to working conditions is just as a difficult as enforcing consistent application of any policy in a large organization.

The question then, to me, is whether or not Starbucks can find a way to ensure that this policy is actually adhered to. And at any rate, good on them for at least making the attempt.

Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by MeVfm on Friday August 15, 2014 @08:50PM (#8185032)
> Companies are not inherently evil

You're right, companies are inherently amoral. If their pursuit of profit happens to be moral, all the better, but don't expect them to rescind immoral policies if it means it'll hurt profit and nobody with any power is around to put on pressure to make them stop.

When they do awful things, those poor persecuted businessmen can always count on apologists like you to come to their defence though.

Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by waps on Saturday August 16, 2014 @01:03AM (#8185454)
Problem with that is that there is no "evil" there is only good and "amoral".

I fully subscribe to one of the basic economic axioms. That people act out of self-interest (whether being a manager in a capitalist system or volunteering in a hospital in North Korea). This is a rule that's true "on average", not absolutely, but it is true in the overwhelming majority of cases you'll look at.

That means "evil" barely ever happens. There are very, very few people who hurt others knowing they'll also hurt themselves in the process (there are, in theory they should be confined to insane asylums). This suggests it's at least a Nash balance.

Almost all people who commit bad acts do so because they are expected a benefit in return. Murder, theft, rape, hell, even suicide bombing ... all come with a benefit to the perpetrator. This makes their actions fit your description of "amoral".

The opposite of good is not your definition of evil. That's merely insanity. I'm not saying that never happens, but it very rarely do. The opposite of good is your definition of "amoral", and because of that it makes a lot of sense to call anything amoral evil.

Having some machine learning experience I might also mention that I've noticed on easy communality in evil versus good. There is this concept of "time horizon" of decisions. Because predicting the world is a cpu and memory expensive process, when evaluating a decision people only simulate X time out. X is called the time horizon. If there is a decision that will have good effects for X-1, and cause a disaster at X, they will make that decision. What we call evil can, to some extent, be simplified as being a "decision with low time horizon" and good is the opposite. Hell, what most saints did can be summarized as making decisions where the time horizon is far longer than their lifespan, which doesn't make sense for most people.

Alternatively one could say that you're trying to let companies get away from being called "evil" by taking a far extreme and then showing that they don't satisfy that standard. That you are presenting a "reductio ad absurdum" fallacy.

Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by learc83 on Friday August 15, 2014 @09:30PM (#8185102)
> Companies are not inherently evil, and companies can - and do - choose to try to do right by their employees

To the extent that it makes them more money, this is true. Providing perks for employees is sometimes necessary to ensure you have good employees, and going above and beyond what's expected can provide positive PR, which in turn can generate revenue.

Irregular retail schedules are an example of what happens when neither the market, nor regulation force employers to do right by there employees.

Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by erichocean on Friday August 15, 2014 @10:06PM (#8185164)
"The market" did just force them to change. Did you read the article?
Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by learc83 on Friday August 15, 2014 @10:54PM (#8185253)
Yeah I did. I was responding to the above post about how companies aren't inherently evil by pointing out that when companies do good, it's not because they are altruistic, but because it's making them more money.

Also whether there is going to be any real change here is debatable. When I worked in retail, schedules were posted 2 weeks in advance, so posting 1 week in advance is hardly "doing right by the employees". The rest of it is a nebulous promise to allow managers more input in creating the schedule and allowing workers to transfer to more convenient locations.

Basically all this change amounts to is something that sounds good in a press release, but is unlikely to actually do much.

Re:Starbucks to Revise Policies to End Irregular Schedules f... by mindcrime on Saturday August 16, 2014 @01:41PM (#8186872)
by pointing out that when companies do good, it's not because they are altruistic, but because it's making them more money.

We could argue about the exact definition of "evil" and "altruistic", but the point is that companies do do right by employees at times, and I'd argue that in reality it's more often than not. What people should keep in mind is that "companies" aren't just some abstract caricature pulled out of Das Kapital or The Communist Manifesto - companies are people, and most people aren't fundamentally evil.

I'll stand by what I said before (albeit perhaps paraphrased a bit) - when companies DO do "evil" vis-a-vis employees, it is not, generally speaking, because they have a generally evil/negative outlook towards employees or because they don't care (at some level). It's more because they are trying to strike that delicate balance where everybody wins, while using imperfect humans to manage things.

Honestly, we'll make more progress towards improving things when we get beyond the socialist/communist caricatures of businessmen as "Boss Hogg" from The Dukes of Hazard, or some "Robber Baron" and deal with the actual issues, not tearing down strawmen.