News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by Lazare on Friday August 15, 2014 @07:27PM (#8184855)
Yep. The City is in every way entirely subject to parliament, and the laws of the country apply within the square mile in every particular the way they do outside it.

The biggest oddity is that since so many people commute into the City, they don't just let residents vote in council elections, but also businesses in proportion to the number of workers they have; an odd but not altogether crazy way of making sure that all stakeholders are represented.

...what any of this has to do with offshore tax havens is a mystery to me. There's only one FSA in Britain, and they don't care where you're headquartered.

Edit: From the article: "the corporation is an offshore island inside Britain, a tax haven in its own right. The term "tax haven" is a bit of a misnomer, because such places aren't just about tax."

Actually, it's not that it's not just about tax; it's that it's not about tax at all. Tax rates are the same in and outside the City. A "tax haven" that's not a haven and doesn't have different tax rates? This is Orwellian stuff.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by UweSchmidt on Saturday August 16, 2014 @04:15AM (#8185693)
Sorry but businesses getting to vote based on the number of workers they have sounds insane and totally undemocratic.

There is a tendency on the internet to downplay the significance of democratic principles and to consider them as quaint, liberal or at odds with libertarianism. Worrying imo.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by colechristensen on Saturday August 16, 2014 @05:29AM (#8185776)
It is literally a single square mile. Nobody's sense of democratic principals should extend so far as to say a single square mile cannot choose to govern itself a little differently.

There are 7,000 actual residents in the City of London and more than 300,000 people work there. To give the huge imbalance of people who work but don't live there a voice in government a mere 16000 non-resident votes are also allowed and divied up to businesses with respect to their size. For the boring local government services provided, this is more than fair.

Also, in general the people who live (especially) and the people who work in the City of London are fabulously wealthy. My heart doesn't bleed for their lost electoral rights (not that I actually believe that the system is unfair) and they all seem pretty okay with it anyway.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by UweSchmidt on Saturday August 16, 2014 @06:01AM (#8185810)
If the people who work there "got a voice in government" that would be quite a bit better. According to the article that's not the case: Corporate management of "Goldman Sachs and the People's Bank of China" would be calling the shots.

Not sure if I understand where you are coming from. How can you not see a fundamental problem with the situation (even if "people are rich" and "just a square mile" would make this particular situation less severe)?

Would you be ok with an expansion of this system to other areas? How do you feel about democratic ideas in general?

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by bokonist on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:23AM (#8186117)
Do you think that the board of trustees for a university should be elected by those students and others living on university owned property? Many universities own far more than 1 square mile, they are essentially mini-cities with their own police, courts, etc. Is it a fundamental problem that universities are not run as democracies?
Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by UweSchmidt on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:39AM (#8186336)
I'll leave this question unanswered as I don't have knowledge about the type of university you are talking about (mine had no own police). If you are truly curious about this topic, your question has probably been thorougly dealt with in literature in the last 100 or 200 years.

If you just put that there to weaken my argument, I'd say let's stay with the topic at hand. We were discussing a local government that's nominally run as a democracy but where corporations have the votes, potentially part of a trend to less democracy if we are not careful (see protesting in the USA, blogging in Russia etc.).

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by bokonist on Saturday August 16, 2014 @12:15PM (#8186617)
I am actually interested in your psychology.

I have a sort of a long term career dream of starting a community/small city as a startup. Such a community would necessarily not be run as a democracy. I have found that there exist "true believers" in democracy, who view it is morally problematic for any community to not be a democracy. Yet such true believers tend to be quite inconsistent in their beliefs - they very rarely complain about college campuses, remote company towns, military bases, research facilities, etc, not being run as democracies. I am thus very interested in how people draw distinctions - what makes it ok for one community or mini-city to be a democracy but not another, where is line? And in designing my city some day - how can I avoid setting off people's triggers whereby they denounce a certain government structure for not being democratic?

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @03:29PM (#8187240)
> what makes it ok for one community or mini-city to be a democracy but not another, where is line?

There isn't one, really. Which is why the Soviet system instituted formally-democratic assemblies in any entity. In principle, it was a great idea; in practice, these bodies were soon hijacked by professional political operatives from The Party, who would steer them in the "right" direction and use them as another tool of control (speak up against the Party line in your factory soviet, and you'd soon be on a train to Novosibirsk). For other insights into that particular form of organization, I'd recommend Bulgakov's "Heart of a Dog".

Whether the limits of the Soviet system where environmental or historical in nature (they didn't have the internet, say), it's an open debate for another day, but I mention it to define one extreme of the theoretical scale: anyone can vote on anything. At the other extreme, you have absolute monarchy: nobody can vote on anything.

Anything in between these extremes is not "absolutely democratic" or "absolutely undemocratic", which is why debate is so fragmented and dependent on specific circumstances. You can have profoundly-undemocratic organizations being run in a substantially democratic way by this or that specific leader, or formally-democratic institutions being run with an iron fist by a single individual.

I think that, pragmatically speaking, the most basic element of democracy is just the acceptance of the existence of feedback. If one is ostracised, isolated or punished for the simple act of expressing a differing opinion, people will feel that democracy is non-existent, that the game is rigged. On the other hand, if differing opinions are given substantial space and even co-opted by rulers, especially in times of crisis, the absence of formal democratic structures will be considered a purely theoretical problem and likely ignored in practice.

Others famously define the basic unit of democracy the answer to the question "can we replace our rulers without violence?". However, this sort of argument can be subverted by putting in place mechanisms for such a replacement and then, by other means, ensuring that they will never be invoked.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by jackgavigan on Saturday August 16, 2014 @02:28AM (#8185538)
FYI, a recent "shake-up" of financial regulation saw the FSA (Financial Services Authority) change its name to the FCA (Financial Conduct Authority), and certain parts/responsibilities of the old FSA were (nominally) hived off to a new Prudential Regulatory Authority (PRA), which falls under the remit of the Bank of England.

Otherwise, I agree 100% with what you wrote.

Re:Tax haven in the heart of Britain (2011) by Retric on Saturday August 16, 2014 @01:54AM (#8185502)
Local governments normally collect more taxes so there are tax advantages. Just not the same scale as offshore tax havens.