News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by biohacker42 on Friday September 11, 2009 @05:44PM (#818198)
I'm not sure if we have it backwards, but the article definitely oversimplifies it. It also makes some embarrassing points for ephasis, plants using antioxidants as defenses, green tea might be, but I doubt many fruits are NOT meant to be eaten by animals.

The health benefits of a diet high in fruits and vegetables are supported by very strong science.

We've also had some very good recent research into vitamins and other antioxidants in pill form. The news there is not so good, it seems vitamin pills may be worse then useless.

With cancer it's more complicated. Some vitamins like C and D have proven anti-cancer properties but in doses that would kill you. In low doses C might actually be helping some cancers, as they can use it as well as healthy cells.

In summary:

Backward? No.

Oversimplified? Yes, it is complicated.

Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by latortuga on Friday September 11, 2009 @06:28PM (#818270)
>> The health benefits of a diet high in fruits and vegetables are supported by very strong science.

Maybe check out http://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2007/12/fruit-and-veg... It is a blog post but it seems to have reasonable sourcing. However, I do agree with your conclusion: it's complicated!

Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by restruct on Saturday September 12, 2009 @01:06AM (#818663)
> I doubt many fruits are NOT meant to be eaten by animals.

But plants did not evolve fruits to make animals healthier. Plants evolved fruits so that animals can spread the seeds.

Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by fauigerzigerk on Saturday September 12, 2009 @04:20AM (#818759)
If you believe in evolution you'd have to put it the other way around: Plants who happened to evolve fruits that got spread around by animals had a higher chance of survival as a species.
Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by restruct on Saturday September 12, 2009 @08:52AM (#818863)
True, but a more accurate description of what you meant is "if you believe in evolution by natural selection, you'd have to put it the other way around."
Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by joe_the_user on Friday September 11, 2009 @08:06PM (#818378)
Complicated, indeed...

I don't see why one should necessarily assume that the diets might prevent cancer before it happens will cure cancer once it happens, yet it seems like the article is making something like an argument for this...

Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by billswift on Saturday September 12, 2009 @08:16PM (#819632)
The actual data presented in the article suggests that anti-oxidants may aid the spread of cancer (metastasis) by reducing oxidative stress on dispersing cells.
Re:Antioxidants and Cancer: Have we got it Backwards? by joe_the_user on Sunday September 13, 2009 @02:49AM (#819897)
Sure, but there's a difference between aiding in the spread of the cancer you are unlucky enough to have and contributing to causing someone to get cancer, which a complex and not fully understood process...