News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by masklinn on Friday September 11, 2009 @03:32PM (#817956)
> Sitting in a train is not stress-free, for one thing.

It's the closest I've ever known to stress-free transportation unless you include limousines.

> here are all these people around you, who you can't just ignore completely

Why can't you? You can't fart in public cause that's bad education, but take a book or a laptop, a PMP and a pair of earbuds and you're off. You can also sleep, many do here in the early trains.

> It's like being at a party where you know no one, and parties are hard enough to deal with even if you know everyone at them.

Uh no it's not, at a party you're supposed to talk to people and socialize. In a train you're supposed to do your own stuff and not bother other travelers.

> if there were enough room for a decent-sized laptop between you and the seat in front

There is. In France there are even the center/4 places tables with even more room. And that's 2nd class.

> you'd still have to put everything away

Put what away? Lift your laptop using one hand and get out.

> whenever the people away from the aisle wanted out

In France's TGV, there's one window seat and one aisle seat. Period. And if you use reservations and are early enough you can pick your seat. I pretty much always get window seat on the upper deck.

> Also, when you're driving, there's always the possibility of stopping at something that interests you, or taking a different route.

You're in a train to go from point A to point B, not to visit Manitoulin Island. And the different route complaint is nonsensical.

> and while you might choose to put yourself in a traveling jail for 12 hours

There is no planned US route even remotely reaching 12h. In a current-generation HST, 12h would be more than 2000 miles in a single trip. That's simply not part of the operational range.

> I took a train when I moved from Alabama to the DC metro area last year

Care = none. We're talking high-speed rail here, not 60 years old trainsets on shit lines.

> and Amtrak, the train I took, is subsidized

So are airports and highways.

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by randallsquared on Friday September 11, 2009 @04:18PM (#818038)
There is no planned US route even remotely reaching 12h.

Last year's current route from Atlanta, GA to Washington, DC was 13 hours.

> I took a train when I moved from Alabama to the DC metro area last year

Care = none. We're talking high-speed rail here, not 60 years old trainsets on shit lines.

The commenter I replied to had said: "Being from India (where the rail system is awesome, even though its not high speed [...]", so we were talking non-high-speed for the purposes of this comparison of how he prefers rail to driving, and I prefer driving to rail. However, you're certainly under no obligation to care. :)

Uh no it's not, at a party you're supposed to talk to people and socialize. In a train you're supposed to do your own stuff and not bother other travelers.

Again, "Also, I dont understand people who prefer driving 8 hours, rather than sitting in a train, stress free and can actually use their time to work/read/socialize", you can see I was responding to ujjwalg, who'd offered up his experience with India's non-high-speed, socializing-appropriate trains. :)

Anyway, it sounds like you're talking about commuting, which I do take a train for, and which I'd be happy to take high-speed rail for, if it was easy to do. I don't mind being on a train for 30 minutes when I have someplace to be. Actually taking hours-long trips by train, however, is not my thing, especially since anyplace a train serves is likely to be served by plane as well, more quickly.

Re:The White House's Vision for High Speed Rail by ujjwalg on Friday September 11, 2009 @04:26PM (#818060)
The commenter I replied to had said: "Being from India (where the rail system is awesome, even though its not high speed [...]", so we were talking non-high-speed for the purposes of this comparison of how he prefers rail to driving, and I prefer driving to rail. However, you're certainly under no obligation to care. :)

The distances are much shorter in India. Moreover, most of the trains have bunks you can sleep on and are overnight trains. If you buy second class ticket between big metros, you are even served dinner and breakfast and all just for $30. Now you can chose between driving and riding a train.