Re:Nepal Human Hair Solar Panel Hoax (CraigHyatt)
by jacquesm on Friday September 11, 2009 @09:35AM
(#817303)
That, and hope. A good rule is that if it looks too good to be true then it probably is. Check and check again before you make a fool of yourself in such cases.
I really don't blame these kids, I blame their teacher and the dailymail.
Re:Nepal Human Hair Solar Panel Hoax (CraigHyatt)
by swwu on Friday September 11, 2009 @01:01PM
(#817679)
Actually, if you read the article, they mention using two probes made of the same metal to eliminate any current generated by the differences in redox potential between them.
Re:Nepal Human Hair Solar Panel Hoax (CraigHyatt)
by ars on Friday September 11, 2009 @06:54PM
(#818303)
There is still a difference. The probes are placed in different things, so the two probes have differing ability to oxidize.
Oxidation of a metal is a much more likely source of electricity than a tree, so much so, that they need a much better experiment before I'll be convinced that the tree is making electricity.
For example, let it run for a long time and check for any evidence of corrosion.
Are there metals that don't corrode? Perhaps palladium?
They could also try a variety of different metals for the probes (both at the same time) and see if they get different voltage readings.
For example look at: http://www.physorg.com/news171643486.html
I don't know anything about physorg.com, it sounds like they should know science - except they don't. The electricity does not come from the tree, it comes from the metal probes.
Cold fusion has the same problem. One person reported how a certain batch of palladium worked great and made energy, but now the palladium is used up, and new batches don't work.
His mistake is that the palladium and the cold fusion had nothing to do with it. Palladium is sometimes refined from nuclear waste, and that batch was slightly contaminated.
Doing science is hard, especially correcting for all the variables. Very few people learn how to do it properly.