News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of College by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @06:23AM (#8172238)
Elon Musk: judging by the fact that he went to a traditional English "public school" (what Americans would call a private school, actually), his family was well-off. Went to the University of Pennsylvania.

Richard Branson: born the son of a barrister and grandson of a knighted member of the High Court. Also attended an English public school. Exceptional for not attending university.

Steve Jobs: son of a mechanic/carpenter (finally someone blue-collar!) and... oh no wait, an accountant who worked as a payroll clerk at one of the first Silicon Valley high-tech companies. Attended an expensive private college.

Bill Gates: son of lawyers, got Microsoft's first OS contract for MS-DOS through his mother's connections to the board of IBM. Attended the University of Washington.

Being merely well-off to start with is also family money.

Re:The Future of College by lutusp on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @11:43AM (#8173406)
> Steve Jobs: son of a mechanic/carpenter ...

Sorry, no. Steve Jobs was an orphan.

> Attended an expensive private college.

Dropped out of Reed College.

> Richard Branson: born the son of a barrister and grandson of a knighted member of the High Court.

These are genetic references, not financial ones. Genetics isn't the issue under discussion.

You managed to overlook the fact that none of the examples had inherited money at the time of their greatest success. Attending an exclusive school is certainly no assurance of later success, often the contrary, and can't be equated with the classic case of inheriting family money.

> Being merely well-off to start with is also family money.

That twists the earlier premise so far as to render it meaningless. And how can the orphan Steve Jobs be described as "well-off to start with"?

Re:The Future of College by rpedela on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @05:09PM (#8175029)
In the US, universities were far more affordable when Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, etc were that age. Harvard like other Ivy League schools was probably still expensive, but many were not. My father (slightly older than them) was able to pay tuition by working in a factory during the summer. He didn't need any loans. Unfortunately that isn't possible anymore. There was a time when you could be blue collar and still get a great education if you were willing to work hard while not being burdened with massive debt after graduation.
Re:The Future of College by eli_gottlieb on Thursday August 14, 2014 @07:33AM (#8176961)
Yes, fine, but my point is: pretending that these men rose to become business magnates despite lacking wealth and background is completely incorrect. Even the lowest of them started within the professional upper-middle class (roughly where you and I probably are), which is already most of the way up the class scale, in percentile terms.
Re:The Future of College by lutusp on Thursday August 14, 2014 @12:31PM (#8178249)
> Yes, fine, but my point is: pretending that these men rose to become business magnates despite lacking wealth and background is completely incorrect.

Not so, and certainly not so in the case of Steve Jobs, an orphan. Each of the stories is of someone who certainly wouldn't have succeeded to the degree they did without personal qualities that transcended their origins, rather than family wealth, the original argument. Richard Branson didn't build his present empire by buying it with his family's money -- he created it out of his wits. Elon Musk is another story of the same kind -- it's hyperbolic to argue that he became successful because of inherited wealth as opposed to personal ingenuity and drive.

> Even the lowest of them started within the professional upper-middle class (roughly where you and I probably are), which is already most of the way up the class scale, in percentile terms.

But this isn't about class -- it might be about genetics, and it certainly isn't about family money, the original offered explanation. For these stories, class and family background are correlations, not causes.

What we're talking about here are stories of exceptional success with no obvious cause apart from personal drive and ingenuity. They can't be dismissed as resulting from high birth or privilege -- it would be more consistent with logic to examine them on their self-evident merits.

Re:The Future of College by JoeAltmaier on Thursday August 14, 2014 @12:33PM (#8178263)
How about: They won the exploding-market lottery by being in the right place and executing well? Just another bunch of upper-middle-class white boys who could get into all the right clubs is another part of it.
Re:The Future of College by lutusp on Thursday August 14, 2014 @12:55PM (#8178371)
> Just another bunch of upper-middle-class white boys who could get into all the right clubs is another part of it.

It's too facile (and clearly somewhat tempting) to argue that race, or old-boy networking, played a part. Most of these people (some of whom I have met) are so driven that the idea of joining a club of rich white guys would seem like torture. Some will argue that they're all Aspies anyway, thus very unlikely to be joiners of anything.

> They won the exploding-market lottery by being in the right place and executing well?

That makes more sense -- the role of blind chance. When I wrote Apple Writer for the Apple II in 1979, at the time I didn't fully appreciate the vacuum in which I was working, and how my program would seem more remarkable than it was, simply by being the only one.