News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Set Up to Fail: How Bosses Create Their Own Poor Performe... by michaelochurch on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @12:17PM (#8168457)
"Scrum" is often an attempt to take micromanagement, or the low-status programmer culture, and institutionalize it in a way that seems impersonal and policy-based. Hence, the haggling over story points (a low-status behavior, because it refuses to recognize the meaninglessness of the involved currency and the way the team has been pitted against itself). But high-status programmers just ignore that sort of process and work the way they want to.
Re:Set Up to Fail: How Bosses Create Their Own Poor Performe... by vosper on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @02:07PM (#8169164)
Can you define high and low status programmers / programmer culture? Because the most competent and productive engineer in my office is also the biggest sticker for the planning / pointing process.

Ultimately I think Scrum needs to be for the team, and the process should be defined by the team. If pointing stories isn't working then the team can stop doing it (we pay it lip service, but that's about it). But you do need some way to agree on what's to be done and who's going to do it.

Re:Set Up to Fail: How Bosses Create Their Own Poor Performe... by sheepmullet on Wednesday August 13, 2014 @07:09AM (#8172312)
The planning/pointing process can only benefit people with high status. Rules don't really impact high status employees.

If somebody with high status doesn't meet expectations we tend to think the problem is with the expectations; if they are low status we tend to think the problem is with the person.

In the same way the high status employee has a lot more say over the way story points are allocated and how the work is allocated.

I've been low-status before despite being just as good as everyone else in the team and I've also been high-status despite being one of the worst in the team.

When you are low status people focus on your mistakes. When you are high status people look at your successes and overall contribution.

Re:Set Up to Fail: How Bosses Create Their Own Poor Performe... by wisty on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @12:46PM (#8168633)
If it's a choice between democratised micromanagement, and highly political feudal lords and their serfs, which would you pick?

OK, having the right people manage might be better. Can you point me to an institution that's managed to consistently pull that one off?

Re:Set Up to Fail: How Bosses Create Their Own Poor Performe... by SDGT on Tuesday August 12, 2014 @02:03PM (#8169141)
> Can you point me to an institution that's managed to consistently pull that one off?

Sure, hoards of shops founded and run by developers with PM's who have actually done the grunt (coding) work in the past.

I've noticed that this problem usually pops up when the PMP certified suits end up managing technical staff.