Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem
by danbruc on Monday August 11, 2014 @07:36AM
(#8162840)
Is there any good definition of free will at all? Given somebody is in situation X and has options A and B then the choice to do one or the other can either be completely at random or on the other extreme depend completely on the situation X (including the person with the brain and all the memories and the complete environment). Or it may be a mix of both where the situation affects the probability distribution. But none of these scenarios matches what I would call free will, making a choice that is neither random nor a deterministic consequence of the situation, but I can not even think of any mechanism outside of the spectrum from randomness to deterministic consequence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem
by eseehausen on Monday August 11, 2014 @01:32PM
(#8164225)
This issue you're running into is why I think trying to think about free will in that context is a category error. The concept doesn't make sense when it's something that depends on randomness or determinism. Instead, I think it's useful to think about how we use it in actual practice, which is generally something like, "is a person more or less self-directed" where self-directed means that their actions are consistent with their observed character and expressed desires. That's not particularly satisfying if you're raised in a culture that puts a lot of value on free will as a concept, but I think it may be the best we can do.