News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by aaronblohowiak on Monday August 11, 2014 @01:06AM (#8162009)
To me, this argument is a strong defense of the "self", but does not address the "free" part at all. It is like saying that a rock is free to weigh more than a marshmallow because of the complicated history that lead it to being this rock.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @01:53AM (#8162116)
Exactly my thought as well.

I believe we keep telling us stories about a "free will" because we're afraid of that thought because we misinterpret it. Most people answer unreflected things like "that would be like living in a prison". Also we have learned to judge everything and everyone. How can we expect people to completely drop all kinds of judgement?

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by Tomte on Monday August 11, 2014 @05:18AM (#8162565)
Why would we stop judging?
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @05:56AM (#8162667)
Not sure I understand your question correctly.

We should stop judging.

Because nobody has been able to show "free will" is more than just another belief (as in religion) and it is therefor no basis for rational discussion. And if free will does not exist, our concepts of "merit" (on the positive side) or "guilt" (on the negative side) are worthless and should be abolished.

That's why there should be no judging at all.

(Note: No judging does not mean nobody goes to prison for crime. It simply means we must redefine "punishment" as "a neutral sanction" or better: "protection from happening again".)

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by Tomte on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:19AM (#8162933)
> We should stop judging.

If there is no free will and we still judge, we cannot not judge!

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:44AM (#8163002)
Yes, we can!

All there needed to be was for the handful of initial variables that were set at the "beginning of our universe" to have such values that their interaction over time would lead us to rational thinking and therefor our understanding that there is no "free" will.

Simply put: If I explain to you why free will is an illusion and you stop judging, then it wasn't a "free" will. It was a cause-and-effect situation.

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by Tomte on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:10AM (#8163290)
You should try and get implication and conclusion sorted out. I think you slipped in a negation somewhere.

If there is no free will and I stop judging, then yes, obviously we can stop judging.

But if there is no free will and after your explanation I still judge, then no, we cannot.

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:58AM (#8163513)
Let's put it like this:

My explanation would be only 1 variable in your system (out of an infinity of others, if you assume that you can always continue to "zoom in").

Now, if that 1 variable does anything to your decisions or not depends on all the other variables as well, i.e.: You may have gotten a very religious education which may lead you to accept beliefs put forth by other as "the truth", without questioning. Since one major point of religion is "free will", I'm not sure "my explanation" would do anything to your decision making.

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Monday August 11, 2014 @11:00AM (#8163526)
If there is no free will, then all we do is predetermined and arguing is pointless, because, by definition, it cannot change anything because everything is predetermined.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @11:36AM (#8163674)
The arguing is just 1 variable in the system. It was bound to happen because it was caused by other variables (i.e. us being online, someone posting the article, etc.) and it will interact with other variables to lead to some amount of change. It's not something that "we control". (Our brains do, but they are the result of other variables, such as our genome, environment, etc.)
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Monday August 11, 2014 @02:14PM (#8164431)
I don't get that - with predetermination, there are no variables at all. Its all a mechanism set in motion at the big bang, turning inexorably toward ultimate entropy. We're just some predestined middle state right now, with no choice and no say.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by eseehausen on Monday August 11, 2014 @02:47PM (#8164598)
All that would mean is that you were incorrect before when you had some mystical idea of what choice meant. Choices still matter (in the most literal sense: they are material). If complete determinism is true, the choices we make and the things we say are part of the causal stream that leads to other actions, even if that stream could only ever go one way.

On top of that, how would choice make more sense in a random universe?

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Saturday August 16, 2014 @08:42AM (#8186046)
Mystical? I think the meaning of 'choice' is well-understood. I believe philosophers have reinvented the meaning so they can put it into their wholly imaginary framework of doubletalk.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by eseehausen on Monday August 18, 2014 @09:34PM (#8195653)
If you mean choice as something external to whatever deterministic/indeterministic framework we use to understand physical systems, it is mystical. If you mean choice as in "I wanted to do something and then I did it", which is the commonly understood meaning of choice, there is literally no conflict with determinism.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by danbruc on Monday August 11, 2014 @07:05AM (#8162785)
Now how do you stop judging without free will?
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @07:30AM (#8162831)
That's an easy one:

If somebody explains you the reason why judging does not make any sense and you understand it and apply it to your life, then it wasn't "free will". It was causality - you're doing it because of a "variable" (the explanation) that was part of your "system". Obviously, there is a huge number of other variables participating in your decision, not just one, and you could track them on a micro level (molecular) as well as on an macro level (i.e. your family, friends, wealth, etc.).

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by danbruc on Monday August 11, 2014 @07:55AM (#8162880)
But without free will nobody can decide to tell you something and influence your future decisions. If there is no free will then watching the universe over time is just like playing back a movie, maybe with some unpredictable plot twists due to randomness. Me writing this comment was predetermined - at least with some probability - since the big bang. All the things humans have done, from fighting wars to writing all the books to inventing and building all the human made things in the world, are predetermined. And while I think that there is no free will trying to imagine that everything around me is the result of a mindless process is more than my poor brain can do and therefore in everyday life I just keep pretending I have free will.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:35AM (#8162977)
> If there is no free will then watching the universe over time is just like playing back a movie, maybe with some unpredictable plot twists due to randomness.

Yes, rational thinking dictates exactly this conclusion (the apparent randomness being introduced by our current understanding of quantum physics).

> And while I think that there is no free will [...] in everyday life I just keep pretending I have free will.

Well, Rome wasn't built in one day. Our whole culture was built upon the illusion of "free will" (same goes for other beliefs like magic, gods, etc). It's a good exercise to remind oneself about this when we get all worked up over something or somebody.

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:54AM (#8163025)
I call hypocrisy - convincing folks there is no 'free will' has got to be the ultimate in fooling oneself!
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @08:58AM (#8163043)
I don't convince, I argue.

If the logic has a flaw, please let me know, I'm interested in being as close to the "truth" as possible.

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Monday August 11, 2014 @09:34AM (#8163157)
The flaw is, what's the point? If its true, it has no effect. If its not, your arguing a falsehood.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dan_bk on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:07AM (#8163276)
> If its true, it has no effect.

As discussed, it would mean, for example, that we cannot judge anyone (and at the same time claim to be rational).

To give an example: The death penalty should no longer exist, because it is solely "justified" by judgement along the lines of "person X is evil and therefor doesn't deserve to live". There are no evil people, only people who do what they have to do, given the variables in "their system". That means there should be no "punishment", but emotionally neutral measures to prevent the suffering from happening again (i.e. locking the person up). It's pretty clear to me that a much more humane society will be the result of this understanding. And who wouldn't want that?

Edit: "rational" in the sense of "logical".

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by JoeAltmaier on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:11AM (#8163294)
If there is no free will, then it is spurious to claim anyone is 'rational'. That loses all meaning.
Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by dragonwriter on Monday August 11, 2014 @10:15AM (#8163313)
> If there is no free will, then it is spurious to claim anyone is 'rational'. That loses all meaning.

No, it doesn't. I mean, the rational actor model is evidently false for lots of other reasons, but its a purely mechanistic model but for the utility function (on whose nature it is completely neutral), so rationality is just as compatible with the non-existence of free will as it is with the existence of free will (in fact, rationality requires either that there be no free will or that it be confined entirely within the utility function.)

Re:Conway's Proof Of The Free Will Theorem by baddox on Monday August 11, 2014 @02:39AM (#8162219)
If the rock told me that it intuitively perceives itself as being free to weight more than a marshmallow (and I didn't otherwise have reason to believe I was hallucinating), then I would have little trouble conceding that the rock is free to weigh more than a marshmallow.