Ayahuasca (never tried it, do not intend to) is by all accounts a very strong psychotropic. It regularly induces nausea and I've only heard of it being used in semi-ritualistic settings. Also, it's a bitch to concoct apparently - i.e., you don't get this "off the shelf"
shrooms, um Magic Mushrooms, have a different psychoactive main ingredient (psylociyin?) to Ayahuasca and have a short shelf life (unless dried I think) and are seasonal.
LSD (Acid) is easily sourced, you have to trust that it's pure but you could find out from someone who's had part of a batch. LSD is easier to regulate than magic mushrooms (uh, 50 is about a dose? who knows...) because you can take half a tab to start with.
Do your own research, ignore the mysticism (it's so tedious), go have your own experience, and see for yourself.