News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lubuntu: Floats Like a Butterfly, Stings Like a Bee by jerf on Thursday September 10, 2009 @12:13PM (#815524)
Terrible article. Whines about choice, then concludes the latest choice is compelling. Whines about fragmentation in Ubuntu, then at the very end shows that he does understand that it is in fact all Ubuntu and all these "variants" are just different installed packages. Spends about half of an article with some interesting tidbits whining in general.

And in the end, his conclusion is wrong, too. The different between a 200MB and 300MB memory load is not all that significant; if your machine can run, it can run the other, with a bit of swap. (In either case you're looking at swap anyhow, and bear in mind that I'm accounting for the fact we're talking about soft limits, not hard ones. 300MB actual MB is different than 200 actual MB on a 256MB system, but memory doesn't work that way, it is always fluctuating up and down. 200-ish isn't all that different than 300-ish.) If you've got 256MB of RAM, you'll pretty much be in the same dire straights with either system, and comfy at 512MB; if you only have 64 or 128MB, you're screwed with both choices. So, this is a pretty narrow window of applicable results.

It should be broken into two articles, one about memory consumption, and one which contains all the whining. Then I could ignore the second one.

There are no comments on this comment yet.