Crazy and technically capable are not mutually exclusive characteristics. Nor does a single joke somehow 'erase' a career. I'm not sure why you would think that.
I think it would be irresponsible to not consider a person's mental stability when considering them for any kind of relationship, particularly as an advisor.
A joke written 20 years ago does not erase this.
It's really this simple folks: it is irresponsible to go around say dumb things like "never take this person as an advisor because they are literally crazy" when we have demonstrable proof that they are more than capable in that regard.
I don't see why this is controversial.