Re:Plot Thickens as 900 Writers Battle Amazon
by pbhjpbhj on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:18AM
(#8152607)
>I don't see how the publishers are evil in that situation. //
[Some made up numbers!]
The paperback costs $10. The publisher removes virtually all the direct production costs of creating the book itself (but obv. not the author, editor, type-setting, marketing and such which remain the same or lower). The publisher puts up the price of books because, hey, why use technology to open access to arts and information when you can use it instead to increase the wealth gap.
Yes, as I indicated, there may be extra utility in ebooks and that enables them to increase the price. But, with no price increase they still make more profit.
Yes, it's just capitalism; it's evil.
Re:Plot Thickens as 900 Writers Battle Amazon
by res0nat0r on Friday August 08, 2014 @01:58PM
(#8154158)
Capitalism is now evil?
Re:Plot Thickens as 900 Writers Battle Amazon
by Joeri on Friday August 08, 2014 @03:34PM
(#8154635)
No, it's a tool, and like any tool it's intrinsically amoral. The morality is derived by the wielder. When capitalism is used as an excuse for immoral behavior, the tool becomes how it is wielded.
Re:Plot Thickens as 900 Writers Battle Amazon
by res0nat0r on Friday August 08, 2014 @04:08PM
(#8154771)
Charging the public for an e-book, at a price some are willing to pay is immoral?
Re:Plot Thickens as 900 Writers Battle Amazon
by Joeri on Friday August 08, 2014 @05:36PM
(#8155181)
No, but some of the things that have been said and done in this negotiation were objectionable, and whitewashing all of it because 'hey, capitalism' is too easy. Nobody forced either side in this negotiation to harm the authors.
Amazon believe a low priced e-book market would generate more profits overall. So they priced low anyway. That, in turn, was their right.
I don't see how the publishers are evil in that situation. What would you do if a reseller was convinced your product was priced too high, and they wanted you to slash prices? The standard advice on Hacker News is "raise your prices".
Amazon appears to have been right, but it was hardly obvious. And low pricing may not apply to all books. For instance, I don't release my books on kindle because of the low pricing structure for self published books.
(Amazon gives 70% royalties for kindle books priced $2.99-$9.99, but only 30% for pricing above and below that, IIRC. The optimal price for my books on my own site is above $9.99, so I don't want that deal)