Re:Poll: I disagree with you, is it ok to downvote you?
by will_work4tears on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:31PM
(#8149675)
Why do you feel that something that is incorrect (even blatantly) isn't useful? I have often observed a thread where somebody ignorantly spouts something and is taught appropriately. I've learned stuff from those and left with a net positive. The original poster might never admit to being wrong, or changing his world-view, but I certainly have many times.
Re:Poll: I disagree with you, is it ok to downvote you?
by chrisBob on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:46PM
(#8149772)
I have had responses actually change my mind, and try to respond as such. I agree that you don't see it much though
Re:Poll: I disagree with you, is it ok to downvote you?
by jobu on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:51PM
(#8150076)
In this case "blatantly incorrect" meant lies with a likely ulterior motive. Off the top of my head I can't think of any case where this has been an issue on HN, but I have seen it on other forums where marketers try to spin problems with their products.
Re:Poll: I disagree with you, is it ok to downvote you?
by chc on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:24PM
(#8149626)
Comments that add nothing to the conversation are noise, and noise necessarily harms the signal-to-noise ratio.
Re:Poll: I disagree with you, is it ok to downvote you?
by walterbell on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:33PM
(#8149691)
What if such a comment was the only one? Is is better that the OP observe no votes and no comments, or a single comment saying "Thanks!"?
My rule of thumb is to upvote if the comment is insightful or has information I find useful. Downvote if it seems blatantly incorrect, mean, overly negative or is actively trying to make the conversation worse. Otherwise I just ignore it.