That's not quite accurate. It's on a per-URL basis, not properties. Webmaster Tools asks you to verify the different _sites_ (HTTP/HTTPS, www/non-www) separately because they can be very different. And yes I've personally seen a few cases - one somewhat strange example bluntly chides their users when they visit the HTTP site and tells them to visit the site again as HTTPS.
> This means that even if you 301 every http page to https when you transition, all of your current rankings and pagerank will be irrelevant.
That's not true. If you correctly redirect and do other details correctly (no mixed content, no inconsistent rel=canonical links, and everything else mentioned in the I/O video I referenced), then our algos will consolidate the indexing properties onto the HTTPS URLs. This is just another example of correctly setting up canonicalization.
By the way, if you're moving to HTTPS, following our site moves guidelines:
https://support.google.com/webmasters/topic/6033102?hl=en&re...
specifically, the site moves with URL changes:
https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/6033049?hl=en&r...
But you did say you have a client with an issue. I suspect they either implemented the move to HTTPS incorrectly or something else is going on. Please ask for more help at our forums:
https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!categories/webmaste...
Oh, and you can't do a change of address from http://www.whatever.com to https://www.whatever.com - you don't allow it!
Until they clear up that ambiguity it seems risky to go TLS only for exactly the reason you cite.
Imagine instead they had added "lack of https" as a ranking factor worth -3. The rankings on the page would have changed exactly the same way.
"not having an inbound link" can be thought of as a negative without changing rankings. In the example above, if getting an inbound link from apple.com would move you up 4 points, then if B got a link from apple that would put them at 22 to A's 20. If instead "not having a link from apple" was worth -4 points, then A would be at 16 and B at 18.
Google treat the http and https versions of a domain as SEPARATE PROPERTIES. This means that even if you 301 every http page to https when you transition, all of your current rankings and pagerank will be irrelevant.
You can verify this behaviour for yourself in webmaster tools.
I suppose this is because it's possible to serve up different content on http/s, but really, who does that?!
In short, don't do this until google rethink their stance on what counts as a property. I'm currently nursing a client with a 30% revenue hole as a result of this.