Re:Wikipedia reveals Google 'forgotten' search links
by ghaff on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @05:24PM
(#8144941)
It is an interesting corner case. We'll increasingly have the ability to setup cameras that can be algorithmically controlled, perhaps using machine learning approaches to take photos based on autonomous evaluation carried by robotic vehicles. I think most would argue that the deployer of the camera is still the photographer.
However, how is that really different if--in this case--the photographer had deliberately given a bunch of monkeys cameras that they could fool around with and take pictures of each other or whatnot? In both cases, you're essentially creating the opportunity for autonomous entities to take photos under only somewhat understood conditions. And how different is that really from this case?
Levels of abstraction and indirection in the creative process. Do you draw a line somewhere?
(Mind you, in this case, IMO there's a pretty clear presumption that the human photographer owns the copyright and Wikimedia is playing with fiddly legalisms that aren't appropriate in this context.)
However, how is that really different if--in this case--the photographer had deliberately given a bunch of monkeys cameras that they could fool around with and take pictures of each other or whatnot? In both cases, you're essentially creating the opportunity for autonomous entities to take photos under only somewhat understood conditions. And how different is that really from this case?
Levels of abstraction and indirection in the creative process. Do you draw a line somewhere?
(Mind you, in this case, IMO there's a pretty clear presumption that the human photographer owns the copyright and Wikimedia is playing with fiddly legalisms that aren't appropriate in this context.)