News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:19PM (#814469)
Aren't humans also differentiated from machines in that the latter are designed, while humans are not designed?

Machines are just an expression of humans' extended phenotypical effects on their environment.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joeyo on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:25PM (#814476)
Is that actually a quantifiable distinction? Does how something is constructed have any affect on it's properties? (assuming equivalent precision of the tools involved)

Building a car by hand versus building one with a modern robotic assembly line both yield the same output.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:33PM (#814490)
Construction implies design.

Evolved entities (read: complex entities) are not designed.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joeyo on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:47PM (#814513)
Ok, but how is a constructed object and a ... (randomly? naturally? what ever word you want to use) evolved object quantitatively different?

One could follow all the steps involved in getting a human from his evolutionary ancestor to his current state by using a pair of magic tweezers to make each mutation in the genome happen at the right time and in the right way. Could you tell the difference based on the result?

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @11:03PM (#814538)
Yes, you can easily tell the difference between entities that have evolved by natural selection, and constructed entities.

(BTW, mutation is random, but evolution is not a random process).

Two example quantitative differences (although, I'm not sure why the specific exclusion of qualitative differences):

1) The human eye, for example, has flaws (that are solved in other similarly evolved eyes) that an engineer laughs at - if you were building a human eye, you wouldn't make the same "mistakes". The deviation from the "better" version is measurable.

2) Evolved entities exist because of procreation. And their only reason for existence is to assist genetic material to replicate. Constructed objects reproduce exactly 0 times and have 0 genetic (or other replicator material).

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joeyo on Thursday September 10, 2009 @12:09AM (#814624)
I think we are arguing at cross purposes here. I'm not arguing what we call evolution doesn't lead to machines very different from the ones that we might chose to engineer ourselves. Rather, I am arguing that, as far as I can tell, I could, given enough time, money and energy, construct a living being using methods very different from natural selection and get the same result. In other words, I don't see why there is anything special about the path taken (some paths may require less energy though. ;-) )

Therefore, I don't consider designing vs evolving as a good way to separate machines capable of consciousness from machines not capable of consciousness.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Thursday September 10, 2009 @12:30AM (#814643)
There is something very special about the path taken (although this phrase is a little misleading) in evolution - not from a design perspective, but from a result perspective - evolution by natural selection is neither a random process, nor a goal-directed design.

Organisms (and by extension, or by reason) are alive because their ancestors have been lucky enough to survive long enough to have offspring.

Note, I'm not arguing that machines cannot be capable of consciousness.

But I am saying that constructed machines are necessarily distinguishable from organisms primarily because they're designed with a goal in mind (unlike organisms - these aren't designed but are the result of the co-operation of genes into higher levels of complexity, team work that has happened to be useful to the survival of the replicating matter - DNA, RNA, or possibly other such material elsewhere in the universe).

I would posit that because of the evolved nature of organisms, there may be flaws in their consciousness (e.g. through chemical imbalance, irrational deduction etc.). It is more likely that machines that are designed for intelligence & consciousness would be gifted (or cursed, depending on your convictions) with perfection, rationality, normalcy, as attributes, or at least their designers would attempt that.

So the the nature of their consciousness would be qualitatively different from that of organisms.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by wensing on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @11:30PM (#814576)
The human eye, for example, has flaws (that are solved in other similarly evolved eyes) that an engineer laughs at

What are those flaws, if you happen to know? I'm curious.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @11:44PM (#814595)
In his 1986 book, The Blind Watchmaker, Dawkins comments:

Any engineer would naturally assume that the photocells would point towards the light, with their wires leading backwards towards the brain. He would laugh at any suggestion that the photocells might point away, from the light, with their wires departing on the side nearest the light.

Yet this is exactly what happens in all vertebrate retinas. Each photocell is, in effect, wired in backwards, with its wire sticking out on the side nearest the light. The wire has to travel over the surface of the retina to a point where it dives through a hole in the retina (the so-called "blind spot") to join the optic nerve.

This means that the light, instead of being granted an unrestricted passage to the photocells, has to pass through a forest of connecting wires, presumably suffering at least some attenuation and distortion (actually, probably not much but, still, it is the principle of the thing that would offend any tidy-minded engineer). I don't know the exact explanation for this strange state of affairs. The relevant period of evolution is so long ago.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by gaius on Thursday September 10, 2009 @02:33AM (#814781)
You often come across odd stuff like this in machinery. The usual reason is that it made fabrication (or access for repair) easier. Engineering is all about tradeoffs, the "right" design is just one of them.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by wensing on Tuesday September 15, 2009 @11:59AM (#824080)
That's really fascinating--thanks for elaborating.

That said, this isn't, for me, a strong refutation of design. Perhaps the designer's purpose was to create creatures with imperfections such as these, with the higher purpose of communicating something deeper.

Or, is there any way of knowing that we won't some day discover there is a very good reason for this?

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joeyo on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @11:42PM (#814590)
An example of something that joubert is referring to is the fact that photoreceptors (rods and cones) in the human eye are actually located behind the retinal ganglial cells, nerve fibers, and capillaries. So light has to pass through a layer of tissue before being detected. One consequence of this is the blind spot.

An engineer would probably try a different ordering.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by netsp on Thursday September 10, 2009 @01:03AM (#814684)
The more I think and learn about evolution as something abstract (IE something that can exist in principle only, happens to be embodied in biology and could be embodied elsewhere), the more I think that evolution is creation. At the very least it is so similar to "creativity" that any discussion on the topic would probably quickly degrade to boring semantic argument.

From this I think there are two potentially interesting products:

- Evolution by natural selection may be usable as an engine of machine consciousness. Some variant of evolution may be at the core of our own consciousness.

- Evolution by natural selection is a mechanical process that we can "take apart" and understand relatively easily. It also happens to be the engine of the process that created species. Happens to be. Even if the evolution of species had never happened, evolution would still exist in abstract. This put it in very good position to be discovered. Perhaps there are equally powerful concepts waiting to be discovered. Perhaps one of them is at the core of our own creativity. Perhaps one of them can be at the core of machine consciousness.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by billswift on Thursday September 10, 2009 @08:40AM (#815115)
Eliezer made what I think was a similar point in posts at Overcoming Bias and Less Wrong; he also pointed out that evolution is really stupid. If we can understand the result of an evolved process, we should, using intelligence, be able to do much better. The key is understanding.