Re:Wikipedia reveals Google 'forgotten' search links
by evv on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @02:03PM
(#8143882)
So the question remains: is there a copyright at all?
Was the photo really produced "solely" by the animal? No. You couldn't exactly say that a monkey with a camera lives in a natural environment.
The real talent here was preparing the camera for primate use, giving the camera to the monkey, somehow getting it back, and developing the photo. The work absolutely owes its origin to a human being. This is an unambiguous case: the man owns the copyright.
Re:Wikipedia reveals Google 'forgotten' search links
by brigade on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @02:18PM
(#8143979)
Techdirt did a good bit of analysis back when the camera owner was issuing takedowns and concluded that it's almost certainly public domain under US, UK, and international law - https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110713/11244515079/can-w...
With an aside that if it's not public domain, the Indonesian government is actually the most likely copyright holder
Re:Wikipedia reveals Google 'forgotten' search links
by cma on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @02:50PM
(#8144149)
Yet the man could do all the same creative stuff, giving the camera to a child instead, and the copyright wouldn't be his.
Re:Wikipedia reveals Google 'forgotten' search links
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @02:08PM
(#8143919)
Huh. I'm thinking, the law actually could be pretty specific about who pushed the shutter button. IT wasn't the man.
Laws aren't generally written in some context-agnostic way, like a philosophy class works out after a bull session. Its lawyers writing about what's at issue at the time.
"The term "authorship" implies that, for a work to be copyrightable, it must owe its origin to a human being. Materials produced solely by nature, by plants, or by animals are not copyrightable."