News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by rabidsnail on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @07:59PM (#814243)
We have no definition of consciousness, so it's impossible to say whether machine consciousness is possible, or whether we have it already.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by naveensundar on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @09:05PM (#814348)
Some philosopher said this sometime back regarding Penrose's theory: (I can't find the original so might be a bit different) "Quantum Computation in microtubules is as explanatory as magical pixie dust in the brain"

We can substitute pretty much anything for the first noun phrase: " X is as explanatory as magical pixie dust in the brain "

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by chrischen on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @08:30PM (#814291)
I think the definition of consciousness is implied as whatever we humans are experiencing right now. So for a computer to be truly realizing its own existence, it would have to be modeled after ourselves.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joeyo on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:29PM (#814480)
The problem is you have to believe what the computer tells you when it says it has consciousness.

(In the same way that I have to believe you when you say you have consciousness).

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by rabidsnail on Thursday September 10, 2009 @01:10AM (#814693)
Then what's the point? Why would we want to make a machine modeled after humans, which are not particularly well adapted for doing any of the things that we want done in the modern world, when a machine designed to perform practical tasks (like a computer) would be much better?

We shouldn't assume that we humans are the best at everything. We shouldn't assume that we humans are the best at anything, really.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @10:38PM (#814496)
You may perhaps be confusing "definition" with "understanding".

My dictionary defines consciousness thus:

consciousness |ˈkän ch əsnəs| noun the state of being awake and aware of one's surroundings : she failed to regain consciousness and died two days later. • the awareness or perception of something by a person : her acute consciousness of Mike's presence. • the fact of awareness by the mind of itself and the world : consciousness emerges from the operations of the brain.

====

We may not know HOW consciousness comes about, but we do have a definition of what consciousness is.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by beza1e1 on Thursday September 10, 2009 @02:37AM (#814790)
rabidsnail was probably talking about a "formal definition" not a short description in a dictionary. The key to artificial intelligence is to develop a mathematical model of intelligence/consciousness. Something like "An intelligent being is a 5-tuple ..." With this model we can calculate intelligent responses/development and a Turing machine can calculate. Therefore one can implement an AI on a computer.

If there is no such model or we can't find it for some reason we won't develop an AI.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by joubert on Thursday September 10, 2009 @11:00PM (#816732)
Does one really need a mathematical model in order to claim one has a "definition". Isn't a mathematical model's role to "understand" something (and hence predict)?
Re:Ask HN: Do you think machine consciousness is possible? by rabidsnail on Thursday September 10, 2009 @01:06AM (#814686)
awake(p): not in a state of sleep; completely conscious; "lay awake thinking about his new job"; "still not fully awake"

And now we're in an infinite loop.