Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by protonfish on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:01AM
(#8142015)
Don't shift the burden of proof-It is up to HTTP/2 proponents to demonstrate that the benefits are greater than the costs and from everything I've seen the benefits are meager and the costs are large.
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:17AM
(#8142059)
I'm not trying to shift the burden here, but the point made was along the lines of "HTTP2 is rubbish" - I've seen this a lot, with little to back it up.
But I'd say some of the benefits were:
- Server push support - Multiplexed requests/header compression/other performance improvements - Mandatory encryption support
Downsides are (from what I understand):
- Not a plaintext protocol
There may be more downsides, which I'm happy to hear about.
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by jimktrains2 on Friday August 08, 2014 @02:39PM
(#8154386)
> - Server push support
Couldn't a multi-part document already do this?
> - Mandatory encryption support
Couldn't they just have said "OK, HTTP 1.2 MUST be done over a TLS connection?" Also, didn't the TLS-always idea go away recently?
The downsides also include reïmplementing much of level 4 (congestion management, flow control, &c) and all of the complexity that goes with it.
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by protonfish on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @09:06AM
(#8142240)
Mandatory encryption support sounds like a good idea, but isn't that what the article was saying they aren't going to do? I would say the other things you mentioned are features, but not necessarily benefits. Server push is not something I want, and if I did, web sockets are probably a better solution. And those alleged performance improvements have yet to show a significant performance increase on real-world web sites.
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by justincormack on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:28AM
(#8142088)
Here is a thread about issues in serving it efficiently https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/mechanical-sympat...
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by Ono-Sendai on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:54AM
(#8141998)
Are you claiming HTTP2 is not more complicated than HTTP 1.1?
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:11AM
(#8142050)
Is is more complex - why is that inherently a bad thing?
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by Ono-Sendai on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:17AM
(#8142061)
Complexity is bad, all other things being equal, because it takes longer to implement, is more likely to contain bugs, etc..
Re:Strengthening HTTP: A Personal View
by matthewmacleod on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:22AM
(#8142071)
Right, but obviously that's not the case here - there are actual benefits of using HTTP2. The fact that it's more complex doesn't necessarily (and I would argue, definitely doesn't) outweigh that.
HTTP 1.1 is relatively simple, but it's also a bottleneck.