News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by personZ on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:23AM (#8141920)
I assume that it isn't actually orbiting the comet, but instead is just adjusting to follow the same orbit as the comet, right?
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by arethuza on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:27AM (#8141931)
It's being described as a "triangular orbit" :-)

"Rosetta will, follow, at least for now, a three-legged triangular orbit that requires a small thruster burn at each apex. The legs are about 100 km long and it will take Rosetta between three and four days to complete each one."

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2014/08/04/whats-happening-in-r...

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:51AM (#8141988)
Here is a YouTube video from ESA demonstrating the orbit. It will be performing these small thruster (in the order of centimeters per second velocity change) burns to stay ahead of the Comet while doing fine measurements of the acceleration caused by the gravity of the comet.

When the mass and mass distribution has been established, the spacecraft will eventually settle in an orbit about 20 kilometers from the comet and finally down to 10 kilometers.

http://youtu.be/Mf1zsACcXc4

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by 3rd3 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:14AM (#8142055)
It looks like it's only in a triangular orbit while approaching but it will eventually be in an elliptic orbit.
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:29AM (#8142090)
> It looks like it's only in a triangular orbit while approaching but it will eventually be in a elliptic orbit.

Yes, exactly. But since the comet is highly irregular in shape and mass distribution (both are still unknown at this point!), the orbit won't be a perfect ellipse, not even close.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by Throwaway823 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:37AM (#8142121)
Does the shape and mass distribution even matter? It's going to have a center of mass, so once that's located, shouldn't the orbit be close to a perfect ellipse?
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:51AM (#8142185)
Yes, mass distribution and shape have a huge effect in the orbits.

For example, the perturbations from Earth's equatorial bulge causes the perigee of an orbit to shift eastwards (see: Molniya orbit). The Moon's gravity field is very irregular and orbiting the Moon at low altitude is just black magic.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by 3rd3 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @09:41AM (#8142362)
But it will be a stable orbit, right?
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by dalke on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @10:02AM (#8142486)
The issues is that, technically, orbits aren't stable in the sense of being described perfectly as ellipse with a point mass at one focus.

That approximation can describe an orbit for a while, but after time the position will differ from the predicted orbit, until at some point you have very little idea of where it will be.

The time it takes for this to happen is called the Lyapunov time. For example, the Solar System is chaotic that way in the ~100 MY time scale. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stability_of_the_Solar_System .

A Rosetta goal now is to figure out the comet's mass distribution, so that the orbital predictions can be better. The orbit won't be "stable" but it will be more "predictable."

Even then, we expect Rosetta to release gas, dust, and water vapor which affects the orbit. I expect there will be orbital corrections over the next few years.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @10:19AM (#8142564)
tl;dr: no, it won't be a very stable orbit for very long.

One definition for the "stability" of an orbit is that if you give the orbiter a small nudge, it will not radically change its orbit. Lagrangian points L4 and L5 are not stable (with this definition) while L1, L2 and L3 are (only in theory, though, in practice perturbations matter a lot).

Since the mass distribution is unknown, we can't quite predict if the orbit will be stable or not. The mass distribution may be very uneven and there may be spikes in the distribution (due to shape and porosity of the comet) that could cause the orbit to be unstable. The comet also rotates and makes things more difficult.

Now the goal of the crew is to find an orbit that is reasonably stable and predictable given the knowledge of mass distribution they have. Nevertheless, the space craft will probably have to do thrust maneuvers to stay in orbit around the comet.

And once the comet comes close enough to the sun and starts to lose mass to the vapor trail, all bets are off. That almost certainly implies some kind of unstability due to mass changes as well as the drag from the vapor trail. The comet may even break down to several pieces when it comes close to the sun.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by sadkingbilly on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @01:17PM (#8143567)
If a comet breaks up into several pieces, will those pieces continue to travel next to each other in the same direction, maybe re-combining via gravity back into a single rock? Or will they just drift apart?
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by jessriedel on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @04:19PM (#8144624)
Depends on how fast they are ejected from each other. The pieces will (more or less) have an "escape velocity". If they are faster than this velocity they will drift ever further apart. Slower, and they will slowly fall back towards each other.

My understanding is that it's unlikely that they would ever recombine into a solid object since the gravity between them is so weak.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by mikeash on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @11:12AM (#8142841)
Another definition of "stability", perhaps more relevant here is: if you complete an orbit without crashing into the body you're orbiting, does that guarantee you won't crash into it later?

When orbiting a uniformly-dense sphere in an otherwise empty universe, this holds. When orbiting a body that approximates a uniform sphere in a universe where all other large bodies are relatively far away, this mostly holds. But significant deviations from a spherical shape can easily make most orbits unstable.

Little known fact: the Earth's Moon deviates enough from a uniform sphere to make long-term orbits tricky. Wikipedia article:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_orbit

Nice bit about a small satellite released by Apollo 16:

"Instead, something bizarre happened. The orbit of PFS-2 rapidly changed shape and distance from the Moon. In 2-1/2 weeks the satellite was swooping to within a hair-raising 6 miles (9.7 km) of the lunar surface at closest approach. As the orbit kept changing, PFS-2 backed off again, until it seemed to be a safe 30 miles away. But not for long: inexorably, the subsatellite's orbit carried it back toward the Moon. And on May 29, 1972—only 35 days and 425 orbits after its release"—PFS-2 crashed into the Lunar surface.

And this is all without any of the additional trickery coming from outgassing.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by wcoenen on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @05:18PM (#8144912)
It's not so much the shape of the moon but the mass concentrations. The moon has significantly stronger gravity over impact basins. Based on shape alone (low plains) you'd expect lower gravity there.
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by personZ on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:31AM (#8141939)
What a fascinating, seeming convoluted (but clearly intentional and purposeful), flight path. Fascinating stuff, and it's amazing it has that much residual thrust available.
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by Sharlin on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:33AM (#8141942)
AFAIK they're only doing it for a while to measure 67P's mass and density distribution, so they can calculate a "real" orbit for Rosetta later (but it will still require regular adjustments due to the highly irregular shape of the comet).
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:25AM (#8142078)
> and it's amazing it has that much residual thrust available.

We're not talking about propellant residue, that was very well planned ahead.

The spacecraft carried about 1.5 tons of propellant at launch. That gives the spacecraft a delta-v budget that is several kilometers per second.

The next thruster burns (on the triangular "hyperbolic orbits") will be tiny, in the order of centimeters per second.

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by Gravityloss on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:40AM (#8141960)
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by Luc on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:27AM (#8141932)
It's moving under power in a trajectory around it at the moment. I would call that orbiting, even if it's not due to the gravitational pull of the comet.

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn25995-cometmapping-ros...

Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by FranOntanaya on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:23AM (#8141922)
That's correct. And because the orbit forces it to slowly overtake the comet, it needs to slow down periodically to stay at 100km of it.
Re:Europe's Rosetta probe goes into orbit around comet 67P by exDM69 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @07:56AM (#8142001)
> That's correct. And because the orbit forces it to slowly overtake the comet, it needs to slow down periodically to stay at 100km of it.

No, not quite. Remember, we're talking about a three body problem here so any intuition from two body dynamics doesn't really hold.

The spacecraft travels 100km closer to the sun than the comet, but that's a very small fraction of the total distance. When you factor in the small acceleration from the comet body, we can no longer think of the orbit as being a slightly smaller orbit with a shorter period (and thus overtaking the comet).

My best understanding is that the triangular "orbit" is to measure the mass and gravitational properties of the comet in order to orbit as well as scientific goals.