Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by talmand on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @09:37AM
(#8142348)
I thought that was essentially the final admission, that they had to collect everything to be able to filter out what they were actually looking for. If they could target exactly what they wanted then there would be no need for any type of filtering system.
I can't find his talk online, so I'll just attempt to summarize one of his points. Basically, he said that in 2000-2001, he had developed SIGINT algorithms for selectively monitoring communications of the "bad guys", within some low n-degrees of separation. He also put in protections to make sure that the identities of all targets were encrypted, until proper legal process allowed the NSA to decrypt them (I was unclear who held the keys). He said that his superiors happily implemented his solution, but stripped it of all selective monitoring logic and identity encryption. That was the event that caused him to decide to become a whistleblower.
(He also ridiculed the NSA's defense that it's too hard to separate domestic communications from foreign ones, since, after all, the IP addresses and phone numbers can be disambiguated by simply looking at the first couple digits.)
So, in short, according to William Binney, the NSA is absolutely engaging in non-targeted, bulk data collection.