(Disclaimer; Microsoft employee without a personal office, quite jealous of those with.)
Open offices can only work, IMO, when there's a breakout room, or in general some sort of closed door room anyone can jump into and get things done or have a 4 person meeting. There's just no escaping the need to have privacy for the point of thinking, or even privacy for the point of talking. Maybe there's a perfect job in a perfect world where everything is open, but in my experience, there's a need to get away from the group once in a while, either alone or with a group.
There are these sort of offices available, but the problem is the cost of the context switching, a distraction being an involuntary context switch.
So many people focus on open vs private offices and miss the whole point of which one is better for when.
Realistically, getting the choice seems to be more encouraging.
I'm, unfortunately, at an open office as a cost savings measure type place and without headphones I would get absolutely _nothing_ done.
However, in the case where the open floorplan is simply an office cost savings measure that puts mixed goals in a small collocated area, then yes, headphones..