Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by couchand on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @07:12PM
(#8140071)
Minor clarification: the role of a jury is not to rule on the merit of a motion such as this, but rather to decide the facts of a case. The presiding judge is responsible for deciding the law.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by tga_d on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @07:45PM
(#8140174)
"the role of a jury is not to rule on the merit of a motion such as this, but rather to decide the facts of a case"
I don't think that's correct.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @07:53PM
(#8140197)
Jury nullification has nothing to do with ruling directly on the merits of a motion of the type at issue here. It might involve indirectly considering the merits of a loosely-simialr motion in the course of rendering a criminal verdict, but even that wouldn't apply to this specific motion in its context, since that was not a criminal case.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by superuser2 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:27PM
(#8140488)
Jury nullification is an artifact of the existence of trial by jury and the prohibition on double jeopardy.
It's inevitable that juries can effectively decide law, but it is not their purpose or role.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by rosser on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:27PM
(#8140486)
Motions like this aren't decided by juries, and are orthogonal to Jury Nullification.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by gnaritas on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @07:47PM
(#8140178)
Jury nullification, i.e. deciding on the law itself is a right of juries. It is not true that juries can only decide the facts of a case.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by jrs235 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:52PM
(#8140562)
Jury nullification affects only a single case. It does not affect or determine the law. A side effect is that it may cause prosecutors to stop enforcing certain laws and/or cause the legislative branch to reconsider a law and rewrite it or get rid of it.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by gnaritas on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:56PM
(#8140924)
I didn't say it determined the law, and of course it affects only the single case. The point is they're allowed to make their decision based on whether they feel the law itself is just, not just on the facts of the case.
Re:US Sought Permission to Change Historical Record of a Pub...
by couchand on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @12:15AM
(#8140958)
And I didn't say the jury can't make such a ruling, only that it isn't their role. Which it isn't. Technically I suppose they are "allowed to" in that they aren't explicitly barred from doing so, but really that's just taking advantage of a privileged position.