News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:08PM (#8138691)
Bitcoin tries to do too many things. One of the things that it claims to do is be a medium of exchange of value, i.e. a currency. But its really kind of fails as a currency; nearly everyone actually using it to exchange value is really just using it as a just-in-time proxy for some other currency, i.e. businesses accepting BTC nearly always actually accept whatever the BTC equivalent of a USD (or other fiat) price is at the given moment and instantly convert it back into their fiat currency of choice when the transaction is completed. This is in fact the primary service Coinbase offers (at least, for merchants).

And of course bitcoin has some flaws that make it hard to use as a currency in this fashion; as mentioned in the fanfic, it takes a decent amount of time before you can be confident that the transaction has actually gone through. Delays like that are acceptable in some transactions, but not in all.

Furthermore, this use of bitcoin as an exchange of value is also obscured by the fact that people try and use bitcoin as an investment vehicle, try to use the blockchain for other purposes (e.g. as a digital notary), etc.

All these reasons are why I too have been very skeptical of bitcoin. As far as I'm concerned, most of the "value" of bitcoin is driven by people treating it as an investment vehicle, and this leads to a lot of instability in the value. Without a long-term stable value (or predictable trend), it's hard to actually use it as a currency in its own right; anyone not using it as an investment vehicle is encouraged to hold a bitcoin position for as short a time as possible to minimize their risk.

---

Stellar is a lot more focused. It's strictly acting as a medium of exchange, and in fact encourages you to not even use STR as a currency but instead to just use currency as a currency. STR will have some intrinsic value, but that value will likely be very stable, based on some particular fiat currency (I'm assuming USD but it doesn't really matter which one). It will largely just be used to facilitate exchanges between other currencies, like USD and EUR. Instead, people will trust various gateways to issue credit in the currency of their choice, and trade that credit.

Not only does this insulate all parties from any market instability (as the value of 1 USD is always 1 USD), but the whole mining infrastructure is also gone, replaced by a consensus algorithm, which means transactions happen nearly instantly. On that note, bitcoin fans probably think dropping mining is a huge mistake, but Stellar transactions are already based on trust (you have to trust the issuer of any credit you're accepting), so extending trust to the network itself seems reasonable; you trust that the stellar service provider (stellard) you're connecting to has chosen a set of other peers that will not collude, which prevents you from being defrauded.

These changes obviously mean the investment vehicle angle is gone (well, you can invest in STR, but the price is likely to be stable long-term, stellar has inflation too which encourages spending instead of hoarding), as is any of the other messing about with the block chain. All that's left is the currency angle, and Stellar's approach makes a hell of a lot more sense than bitcoin.

It remains to be seen whether Stellar will get the widespread adoption necessary to actually succeed. But I hope it does, because it looks like it might actually work. Perhaps someday banks will start acting as stellar gateways, enabling nearly-instant transfer between any two people with accounts at participating banks. Basically, Stellar seems like it could do what Dwolla has been trying to do, except without even the 25 cent fee.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by shazow on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:50PM (#8138938)
Bitcoin does precisely one thing (a big ledger), on top of which people are trying to bootstrap many things (currency, asset exchange, smart contracts, notary, other things).

Bitcoin is a distributed trustless ledger tracking inputs and outputs of transactions. It stores it in a blockchain, and determines transaction values using a script that takes some inputs and produces some outputs.

---

As far as I can tell,

Stellar does many things (gateways, trust/debt graph, asset mapping, quality conversion between assets, stellar currency), on top of which people are trying to bootstrap one thing (a big exchange).

Stellar is a centralized trust-based debt graph of arbitrarily-defined assets hopefully backed by trusted gateways. It uses consumer-defined trust and quality (exchange rate) values per asset to other nodes which creates a debit cap for the peer.

The roles between the technology vs ecosystem of Bitcoin vs Stellar are inverted. Clearly Stellar's approach has some benefits (fast transactions, regulation-compatible gateway infrastructure) at some costs (trusted/centralized, bootstrapping risks).

This is about as good of an oversimplification as I can come up with right now.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:42PM (#8139280)
Reasonable simplification, though you're describing this from the point of view of the technology. Yes, technically, bitcoin is a big ledger. But in terms of how people use it, bitcoin is a whole mess of different things that actually conflict with each other (bitcoin as an investment vehicle vs bitcoin as a currency have incompatible goals).

Stellar, technically, is a bunch of things; gateways, trust graph, etc. But in terms of how people use it, it's a single thing: a mechanism for sending real-world money over the internet. And it is real-world money. It's represented by credit, but most people are already operating on credit; they keep all their money in a bank, and the bank tells them how much credit they have, and when they pay for something the vendor accepts their credit and redeems it from the bank (typically by accepting credit from their own bank, rather than physically receiving paper money).

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by rattray on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @10:31PM (#8140713)
I found this a fascinating simplification, and (hopefully) quite a helpful one. It doesn't quite lean me one way or the other between the two, actually.

This does suggest to me, though, that it would have been nice if Stellar had used simple technology (just a distributed ledger, like bitcoin) to bring about the simple use-case (an exchange).

Perhaps that isn't possible, and Stellar truly is the best we could do. But I'm not convinced it is.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by mrb on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:24PM (#8139538)
"nearly everyone actually using it to exchange value is really just using it as a just-in-time proxy for some other currency"

And this is fantastic! It demonstrates clearly that the payment processing aspect alone (without even arguing about the currency aspect) of Bitcoin is a killer application. Being able to receive international payments from any country, in a few minutes, 24/7 (no bank holidays), with extremely low fees, with zero fraud (thanks to transactions being irreversible) beats any current payment processing platform. Quite a few business and financial leaders have noted this. These are also the reasons why Bitcoin is starting to provide great competition to the remittance industry (eg. http://letstalkbitcoin.com/blog/post/in-depth-review-bitpesa)

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by pjc50 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:34AM (#8142112)
zero fraud (thanks to transactions being irreversible)

These are not the same thing at all! Irreversible transactions just means you can't get a refund when you're defrauded. Bitcoin allows recipients to defraud senders at will. I suppose this is popular because the existing system with credit cards defaults to allowing the public to defraud the merchants, but it's not an improvement overall.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by venaoy on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @06:32PM (#8145242)
I strongly disagree. Bitcoin is an improvement for 2 reasons.

1. Fraud come most often from customers (who have nothing to lose), not from merchants (who need to maintain their reputation). As a matter of fact, fraudulent chargebacks cost more than $11 billion a year: http://www.dailyfinance.com/2014/03/20/friendly-fraud-costs-... This is why merchant love Bitcoin's irreversible transactions. This fact alone cuts down most of the fraud that currently occurs with traditional payment systems.

2. In the extreme minority of cases where a merchant is malicious, credit cards are actually terrible. Handing over all your identity details (CC number, expiration date, CVS number, billing address, etc) allows the merchant to steal your identity and make fraudulent charges. Identity theft costs $25 billion a year: http://www.businessinsider.com/bureau-of-justice-statistics-... It is possible but a PITA (and still costly!) to recover from a serious identity theft accident... That's why Bitcoin is an improvement because a transaction authorizes merely a transfer of coins and nothing else, so the malicious merchant cannot cause further damages. On top of that, Bitcoin also allows you to completely get rid of this possibility of even losing coins, via cryptographic escrow systems: two-party trustless escrow (http://blackhalo.info/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/whitepaper_...), or 3-party escrow but where the escrow does not even has access to the funds (https://bitescrow.org/)! All this is completely infeasible with traditional payment systems. Surely, the practicality of such escrow systems will increase overtime. Don't judge Bitcoin based on its current imperfections, but envision what is possible.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:11PM (#8149535)
> Fraud come most often from customers [...] not from merchants

That only works if you're talking about a customer buying something from an established merchant. It doesn't help at all if the merchant is unknown (and therefore has no reputation to protect), or is in fact another person and this is a person-to-person transaction.

This problem is why Bitcoin needs escrow services (which most fiat currency transactions don't need), which of course add extra work and fees on top of what should be a straightforward transaction.

> Handing over all your identity details [...] allows the merchant to steal your identity and make fraudulent charges.

Charges that the credit card company pays, not you.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by venaoy on Thursday August 07, 2014 @04:06PM (#8149859)
> That only works if you're talking about a customer buying something from an established merchant.

True. However my point stands: Bitcoin reduces fraud overall, because most transactions happen with reputable merchants.

> Charges that the credit card company pays, not you.

That's incorrect. In the end it comes from the customer's pocket. Because credit card companies have to have higher CC processing fees to cover higher fraud levels, which indirectly causes merchants to raise their prices. Sometimes it is not obvious (eg. all prices are 1-2% higher in an industry, eg. supermarkets), but sometimes it is more obvious. There is a perfect example from a few weeks ago demonstrating my point: AirBaltic charges a 5.99 EUR fee when processing a CC payment, but not when processing a Bitcoin payment: http://www.coindesk.com/airbaltic-waives-controversial-bitco...

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:18PM (#8155927)
This only works in the utopian world where customers never have a need to issue a chargeback. It's not like chargebacks are some inevitable consequence of the credit card system; they're a feature that the credit card system offers as last resort for payers who cannot resolve their issue with the merchant any other way.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @06:20PM (#8145200)
> in a few minutes

Only if you already have BTC. And a transaction takes more than a "few minutes" to confirm anyway.

Speaking personally, I did not own any BTC, and I did not have an account with an exchange. If I want to buy a few BTC to use in a transaction with someone else, it takes over a week. A few days to confirm a bank account at an exchange, and then 3-4 more days for the ACH transfer to put funds into the exchange, before I can finally buy the BTC.

This is also far from decentralized. Everyone accepting BTC as a just-in-time proxy for other currency are extremely reliant on the exchange they use to do the immediate conversions (e.g. Coinbase). Since you already need to trust some centralized entity, Stellar ends up being a much better model for this sort of payment, because trust can be distributed better (with BTC, Coinbase goes down and you can't accept BTC until it comes back; with Stellar, you can continue to use the appropriate credits for as long as the issuer is still trusted by people), and because you don't need to do any just-in-time conversions, you can just accept USD credit and hold onto that and exchange it for "real" USD at your leisure.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Thursday August 07, 2014 @02:40AM (#8146525)
~10 minutes = a few minutes.

BTC transfers are fast once you already have coins, and this is a reason why its adoption is increasing. People realize that having BTC on hand is useful, so they start holding it. There is a little friction to start adopting it, but once you use it, you truly appreciate many of its benefits!

It is not true that BTC is far from decentralized. There are more than a hundred exchanges in the world as of today. And more and more exchanges open up, so it becomes more and more decentralized over time! It is also false you need to trust a centralized entity. Switching from Coinbase to BitPay is trivial (Overstock did their integration with Coinbase in about 2 weeks).

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Thursday August 07, 2014 @03:05PM (#8149501)
> ~10 minutes = a few minutes.

10 minutes? More like an hour. 10 minutes will get you one confirmation. But that's rarely good enough. 6 confirmations is usually considered a good threshold to protect against double spending, and that means you're waiting an hour.

> People realize that having BTC on hand is useful, so they start holding it.

"People" have been holding it ever since BTC launched, because a lot of people see it as an investment vehicle (albeit a highly volatile one). But BTC is still too volatile for most people to want to hold onto any for any real length of time.

> It is not true that BTC is far from decentralized.

I don't think you understand my argument. I'm not saying that there's a central point of failure that will take down the whole bitcoin network. Heck, that's true of Stellar too, despite the more centralized nature there. What I am saying is that all of the various gateways and exchanges and bitcoin services are still effectively centralized points of failure for the various services they represent. Yes, a company can switch from Coinbase to BitPay, but they won't be able to accept BTC for however long it takes them to move all their services over. Imagine if the company only accepted BTC, that would be a disaster! Similarly, people who use exchanges are taking on the risk of the exchange going under. This is largely due to the fact that people maintain balances with the exchanges, which means the exchange has actually issued them credit, and if the exchange vanishes, the credit is worthless. In that sense it's actually very much like Stellar. In fact, it's nearly exactly like Stellar, because Stellar has both the credit, and has the decentralized trustless currency STR, the big difference is with Stellar people are expected to trade credit, and with BTC, people are expected to redeem their credit with the exchange/gateway in order to trade BTC directly.

Bitcoin does allow you to operate in a completely trustless, decentralized manner where you never leave the network, never deal in any currency except BTC, don't use any online services to manage this stuff (i.e. keep your wallet on your local machine, run the full bitcoin client, etc). But most people don't do that, because it's wildly impractical.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Thursday August 07, 2014 @09:29PM (#8151024)
"But that's rarely good enough"

Yes it is. The vast majority of Bitcoin services and users wait for only 1 confirmation. Waiting for 6 confirmations is "excellent" whereas 1 confirmation is "good enough" (when was the last time we saw a Bitcoin double spend attempt? Never!). But arguing whether 1 confirmation is good enough is a moot point. Bitcoin competes with traditional international payment systems where it is common for transfers to post in 1-3 days especially across weekends or bank holidays ("post" has a specific definition, look it up). So even waiting for 6 confirmations makes Bitcoin faster than traditional systems.

On the other point, true, many people rely on 1 exchange, or place their coins in 1 online wallet service, which makes them vulnerable to incidents typically affecting centralized systems. But this is not a problem inherent to Bitcoin. Not at all. This is solved by educating users, by new services (eg. hardware wallets like Trezor), and by "natural selection" (eg. people who lost coins on MtGox tend to learn their lessons, weak exchanges die, secure ones remain in use, merchants can very easily use multiple Bitcoin processors at once, etc).

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Friday August 08, 2014 @02:45AM (#8151767)
> The vast majority of Bitcoin services and users wait for only 1 confirmation.

They do? Before posting that comment I looked up information on transaction confirmations to check that my "1 hour" figure was correct, and the documentation I found stated that the recommendation is still to wait for 6 transactions, and that you may choose to use as little as 1 transaction for low-risk situations where e.g. you're selling cheap easily-replacable items, but that you should use more confirmations for other transactions.

> So even waiting for 6 confirmations makes Bitcoin faster than traditional systems.

But we're not talking about Bitcoin compared to other traditional systems. The context here is in comparison to Stellar, where conformation happens in seconds (worst case would be minutes, if there's network issues).

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Friday August 08, 2014 @03:59AM (#8151893)
Correct, best practices and doc says to wait for 6 confirmations. But in practice, very few people do this. For example you can send bitcoins to your Coinbase wallet and sell them without even waiting for 6 confirmations.

Let me explain to you why this is okay in practice. A merchant will in general send something to the customer (a seller would ship an item, Coinbase would send an ACH bank transfer, etc). But because sending the service or product to the customer takes time, this gives time to catch double spend attempts. So a merchant considers 1 confirmation as sufficient, and prepares the shipment right away, or initiates the ACH right away. But if in the next hour the 2nd-6th confirmations never come (eg. the 1st confirmation ends up in an orphaned block) then the merchant can cancel the shipment of the item, or cancel the pending ACH.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Friday August 08, 2014 @02:29PM (#8154328)
But that only works when the merchant's half of the transaction is cancelable/reversible. That would never work in, say, a retail store, because the merchant can't catch the guy an hour after he's walked off with that $2000 computer.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Friday August 08, 2014 @08:56PM (#8155888)
Merchants are ALREADY taking a risk with credit cards if, after walking away with a $2000 computer, the guy issues a fraudulent chargeback.

So if a merchant accepts the (non-negligible) risk of credit cards chargebacks, he will accept the (even smaller) risk of a Bitcoin double spend :)

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Friday August 08, 2014 @09:30PM (#8155950)
Yes there's a risk, but it's a relatively small one. There's a chargeback arbitration process, so the guy can't "just issue a chargeback" and be done with it. Also, credit cards are tied to identity, and anyone that issues fraudulent chargebacks may lose their credit card or have other penalties applied. Heck, if it's for a large enough value, maybe they'll get arrested for fraud!

Regarding bitcoin double-spending, FWIW, a few years ago when MyBitcoin.com shut down, they claimed it was due to a series of double-spend attacks that were successful because they were only using 1 confirmation: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=34770.0. More recently, GHash.IO successfully executed double-spend attacks against BetCoin Dice, although it looks like they may have been using 0 confirmations?

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Friday August 08, 2014 @10:22PM (#8156037)
The risk for credit cards is there. And yes it really is as easy as issuing a chargeback and maybe claiming your card was stolen. The only reason it is not occuring more often is because most people are honest, that's all.

I demonstrated to you that accepting bitcoins is safer than accepting CCs in most scenarios like (1) when the merchant's half of the transaction is cancellable, or (2) when the merchant waits for enough confirmations. Now in the last scenario (3) where not only the merchant does not wait for confirmations but the transaction is non-cancellable (eg. guy walking away with laptop), nothing inherent to Bitcoin PREVENTS the merchant from taking all the same precautions he takes for credit cards: for example he could check your ID, check your credit score, verify your presence in his own database of high-risk customers, etc. Bottom line is neither in (1), nor in (2), nor in (3) is Bitcoin inferior/riskier than CCs. In fact it is clearly superior to CCs in 2 out of 3 scenarios. There was a great Mashable article recently explaining merchants love Bitcoin precisely for this reason: http://mashable.com/2014/08/06/bitcoin-retailers/

MyBitcoin claim they were using 0 confirmations, not 1. (But many in the community and myself included think their whole story was a lie and that instead MyBitcoin stole the bitcoins, but I digress...) BetCoin also was using 0 confirmations.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Saturday August 09, 2014 @03:49AM (#8156466)
> The only reason it is not occuring more often is because most people are honest, that's all.

Well that, and the fact that it's fraud, which is a crime, and if you get caught then you will get in trouble.

> I demonstrated to you that accepting bitcoins is safer than accepting CCs in most scenarios [...] when the merchant waits for enough confirmations

Even waiting for 1 confirmation can still take 10 minutes, which is a long time to wait for a lot of transactions, especially in-person transactions. That alone makes it extremely difficult to use Bitcoin for "real-world" transactions as opposed to online transactions.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Saturday August 09, 2014 @06:03AM (#8156636)
Now, eridius, you are starting to repeat a point you already made and that I already rebuked. This is a sign you have no way to "win" this argument and you are merely trying to have the last word :)

So I will repeat the rebuke I already told you, but I will repeat it only ONCE. After this, if you repeat yourself again, I am done here, since you are wasting our time. You are bringing up scenario (3) and my rebuke was "nothing inherent to Bitcoin PREVENTS the merchant from taking all the same precautions he takes for credit cards: for example he could check your ID (like some supermarkets do in the US), check your credit score, verify your presence in his own database of high-risk customers, etc" Therefore Bitcoin with 0 confirmations is no more risky than credit cards to accept in brick-and-mortar stores where the customer can run away after paying.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Sunday August 10, 2014 @04:45PM (#8160677)
How very condescending of you. Feel free to stop talking if you want, but that doesn't mean you have "won".

In any case, your response is completely wrong. I thought we'd discussed this already. Accepting a bitcoin transaction with 0 confirmations is more risky than a credit card, because you have no recourse if you get scammed. With a credit card, the credit card company accepts the fraud risk, not the individual retailers.

Also, credit score? It sounds like you have no idea what you're talking about. You can't check credit score for individual retailer purchases. That's done when applying for a credit card, not using one. Retailers also don't typically maintain databases of high-risk customers, or really do anything at all on the subject of fraud beyond possibly check ID against credit card (which is actually very rarely done unless the retailer has a reason to be suspicious of the card). The only retailers that would ever need to do anything like that are low-volume high-price retailers that can afford the extra effort spend on every customer.

In the end, when you pay with a credit card, the retailer gets confirmation from the CC company effectively instantly that the payment has gone through. It takes just a couple seconds, and at that point the retailer's job is done, they don't carry any fraud risk. If the guy turns out to have been using a stolen card, it's the CC company that pays. But if you pay with bitcoin, and you don't wait for a confirmation, then by definition you have no confirmation that payment has gone through. If you let the customer walk away, and the payment doesn't end up going through, then the retailer is out 100% of the cost, with no recourse.

So yes, retailers that are willing to accept the entirety of the risk may choose to accept bitcoin with 0 confirmations. But not all retailers will do that, and I warrant a majority of retailers won't want to do that. The two classes of retailers that might are 1) the retailers that don't understand the risk they're accepting by doing this, and 2) the retailers that are in a market where their target customers are more likely than most to care about bitcoin and therefore accepting bitcoin will work as a marketing strategy.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by cgjaro on Sunday August 10, 2014 @05:59PM (#8160898)
You know nothing about credit card fraud. When it happens, the retailer has to pay up, and there is a fine and fees. Don't take my word for it. Listen to the CEO of a merchant who tells you how it works: "As Nichols mentioned, credit card fraud is an impetus. When a transaction is found to be fraudulent, the retailer is forced to pay up. To add insult to injury there's also usually a fine. "It's 90% to 95% of the transaction cost and on top of that they'll hit us with a fee, like $20 on top of a $10 sale," Nichols says." Source: http://mashable.com/2014/08/06/bitcoin-retailers/ (which I already gave you 3 posts above, and you apparently didn't read...)

Bottom line: there is, 99% of the time, no recourse for merchants. That's exactly why merchants are so wary of CC fraud! Or else why would they be wary of it if it was all magically covered by the CC company? Food for your thoughts.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Monday August 11, 2014 @01:50AM (#8162109)
You're quoting an online retailer there, not a brick and mortar retailer, so you're already off to a bad start. Furthermore, what he says only applies to the "card-not-there" scenario, i.e. online retailers accepting credit card payments without the physical card. But brick and mortar retailers do in fact have the physical card. Assuming the brick and mortar retailer complied with the rules of their credit card processing agreement, in the card-present scenario, the retailer is not liable for the fraud, although I believe they may be charged a fee.

Bottom line: you're blindly trusting the word of the operator of a sketchy online retailer and claiming that what he says applies to brick-and-mortar stores when it doesn't.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by stevedekorte on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:29PM (#8139203)
"is really just using it as a just-in-time proxy for some other currency"

This is true of every currency. Do you think all the manufacturers, laborers, parts, raw materials suppliers of that [insert any product here] you just purchased in US dollars is paid for with US dollars?

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:35PM (#8139244)
If I pay a merchant USD for some asset, they don't immediately turn around and convert the USD into something else. They hold on to it for at least a little while, and typically all entities (both businesses and people) hold on to very large sums of currency for long periods of time.

They do this because the value is stable, so they know that 1 USD today is worth the same amount (or as close as makes no difference) tomorrow, and the day after. They can hold on to the money for as long as they need, until they want to make another transaction with it.

That's radically different from how nearly all businesses treat bitcion. They never hold any BTC balance. They accept BTC as payment, but they immediately convert it into some other currency, and end up never running a BTC balance. This insulates them from the risk of BTC. Also note that their prices are nearly always based on a fiat currency and the BTC they accept is the equivalent of that currency based on the current market rate.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by st0p on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:47PM (#8139680)
Do you have any experience working in a business that does a lot of international trade? My experience is that they convert to local currency ASAP.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by eridius on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @02:38AM (#8141329)
Is that relevant? Local currency is still currency. A European business that accepts USD and converts it to EUR does not particularly matter, because most businesses that accept USD are not foreign businesses and will keep it in USD instead of converting it.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by lmm on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:47AM (#8142170)
Most currencies act as a reliable medium-term store of value. In countries where the local currency is as volatile as bitcoin, people tend to eschew it for business in favour of more stable foreign currencies. So bitcoin is missing a big chunk of what a currency does.
Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by bad_user on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @08:41AM (#8142143)
> Not only does this insulate all parties from any market instability (as the value of 1 USD is always 1 USD)

The value of 1 USD is always the value people are willing to trade for 1 USD at a given moment, being just a worthless piece of paper otherwise, though because of trust in the US government, the system mostly works. However, there's a reason for why countries prefer gold reserves over fiat reserves, as gold can't be printed. Gold is an example of a real-world offline distributed currency that has been in circulation since the dawn of men. It doesn't have much value either, other than being shiny and a good semiconductor, yet it's still relevant because it's not a currency that a central banking system, like the Fed, can control.

I don't know much about BTC or Stellar or how they work, but it has been my hope that we'll suffer some enlightenment in this century and stop dynamiting and poisoning mountains in the search of gold and thus destroying real value in the process. And I've been hoping that BTC is it. So if Stellar is not an alternative currency, it's not really interesting.

Re:Harry Potter and the Cryptocurrency of Stars by superuser2 on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @11:27AM (#8142934)
You have to understand that the number of people who could benefit from a secure, decentralized medium of exchange over the internet is many, many times larger than the anarchist-libertarian bubble that subscribes to your economic theory.