I hope it won't be a Gish gallop. It indicates that there probably is not one single big case against Bitcoin but many small cases. There is an interesting essay about that here: http://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin%20is%20Worse%20is%20Better
+ I can certainly appreciate the opinion that Bitcoin won't survive in its present form, but I think it's becoming more and more obvious that cryptocurrency in general won't be leaving us any time soon, and I think ignoring Bitcoin's role in that development is extremely foolish.
I still don't understand how bitcoin will ever overcome that obstacle for casual transactions (as opposed to ones in which a 30 minute delay isn't a problem)
A valid transaction which is widely seen in the network will be part of the blockchain with a high degree of certainty, even if it is just a few seconds old. That is not perfect, but the risk of accepting unverified transactions with low volume is very low.
It is important to remember that most systems that we use today have serious flaws, including payment systems like credit cards and cash. Bitcoin doesn't have to be perfect in order to succeed.
If someone could come up with a response to that single flaw, I think most of the others (increasing transactions per second, size of the block chain, etc...) can be overcome.
How likely a credit card chargeback?
My understanding is that if you don't wait for multiple confirmations, then it's not particularly challenging to double spend bitcoins. That's why vendors don't accept a transaction as "good" until multiple transactions have occurred.
And waiting for 30 minutes to pay your restaurant bill would kind of suck.
That's incorrect, there is a significant cost associated with executing a double-spend attack. For small transactions, it's uneconomical to mine an alternate chain in order to execute a double-spend attack.
If you trust the miner a little bit, you can assume that a zero-confirmation transaction be part of the common blockchain. Now it's not advisable to do that when selling somebody a Ferrari and letting them drive off, but it's probably less risky than accepting a credit card payment.
Regarding reputation: I don't quite understand the point. You'd just have to sign your tx with a private key that has a corresponding public key with some reputation attached to it. This is pretty independent of bitcoin itself. You could even build a system where you deposit some amount with a third party (or multiple third parties using a MULTISIG tx), which will reimburse the vendor with that amount if a double spend is executed.
But I think your system would work as well - but it then needs more than just a bitcoin transaction from my wallet.
I'm just trying to think of how we can encourage Restaurants and Grocery stores to start accepting BTC, without getting scammed by double-spends.
I'll be looking foward to seeing it Patrick. I've got my own rant about why BitCoin is (mostly) a terrible, terrible idea but haven't committed any of it to written form as yet.
It does solve the Byzantium generals problem rather neatly, which is good. But I doubt that is why it is used. It is used partly because it suddenly became free money for a lucky subset of people who found you could exchange something you got for free for something valuable (drugs sex etc) - and those were at such high rates that the people receiving the bitcoins were also basically being given free money (when one read the official exchange rates)
This managed to fuel an interesting cycle. I would be interested in seeing if bitcoins exchange slips have affected it's purchasing power at exactly the same ratio or if it is being used as a barter not a currency (in these dark corners of the drug dealing world)
I would also suggest that (afaik) real drug dealers who do real big deals work on serious guarantees of trust. Things like knowing the person you are dealing with, and where their children go to school. So things like trustless currencies in these environments are not trustless - quite the opposite.
Your comment about trustlessness also isn't quite correct; Bitcoin is trustless in the sense that it does not require personal trust for its operation (like eg. the USD does).
That's unrelated to whether trust in the other party is a component in a transaction or not - which, realistically, doesn't have anything to do with the currency being used.
I suggest that anything will work as a medium of exchange especially if you have the threat of death to back up your trust needs. All that is needed is the belief on both sides that bitcoin (or a fleet of Porsches) will hold it's value long enough to complete both this transaction and enough similar transactions to expend the bitcoins received.
So bitcoins don't seem special in this regard - they just seem like cash. And that I don't think is a valid proof they can become a real currency as used in the "trust" economy.
I do accept that trusting the other side won't run off with my drugs is different from trusting the Bank of England won't inflate away my value. But the vast majority of transactions in USD don't have that worry on any sensible timescale either. (Not true of say Zimbabwe)
Thank you - and apologies for commenting whilst tired.
Edit: well the parent (toasted) was commenting up thread on drugs, but now that's massively down thread and this making my comments on drugs pretty weird. I see
I'm still left not really understanding either what Stellar seeks to achieve
If you trust me to speak on behalf of stellar advocates, then my good faith belief is that they'd describe it as something like "We want stellar to be TCP/IP for money." (People who like Bitcoin qua the protocol or blockchain technology rather than qua an asset also sometimes use that metaphor, for what it's worth.) The implication is that "TCP/IP is a fundamentally important technology which allowed other technologies which changed the face of the world" and "money is a crosscutting concern of many extremely important problem domains which you care about."