News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by gnarbarian on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:49PM (#8138254)
I wonder what (if there is one) the logical reason behind this exemption is.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by dpritchett on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:52PM (#8138267)
Reading the DoL's advisory on this [1] suggests that it all hinges on the concept of blue-collar vs. white-collar or production vs. staff employees. I can only imagine that the 'production' employees are seen as more interchangeable and largely incapable of having multiplicative effects on the company's business model. A programmer or accountant who's getting a raw deal can find a better job (where better means pay commensurate with contributions), but a tier 1 help desk tech or factory worker will likely have a lower ceiling on possible pay to begin with, and (more) trouble finding a way to secure compensation that scales with corporate success.

It is surprisingly hard to find explanations for this - the web is choked with articles explaining who's exempt and who's not, but not so many with justifications or reasoning or historical context.

[1]: http://www.dol.gov/whd/overtime/preamble_final.htm

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by walterbell on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:00PM (#8138334)
One reason is lack of organized lobbying by IT/engineers: http://andreas.com/faq-overtime.html

Another round of policy discussion is underway: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/12/us/politics/obama-will-see...

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by logicallee on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:13PM (#8138415)
(Edited to be less sure.)

A third reason might be the argument from market power stemming from the fact that if you can personally create $10 million of cold hard cash value using nothing but a bit of time in front of a computer, and with no long-term detrimental effects on you of any kind, then the fact that you are minting money creates a seller's market (just as there will always be a seller's market for legal currency), and it [might be an argument for] allowing you to work whatever hours you wanted - or sleep in the office, be offered legal drugs, whatever. if you didn't like it you could go somewhere else.

it's very different if you were cleaning staff at any of the same companies. they "need" more protection than you do!

Edit: from your responses it is clear that many people it applies to should also be owed overtime. I was just throwing out one "logical reason".

In addition I've thought of the crazy hours residents and doctors put in - so that high earnings / value add might not guarantee that much market power, if the conditions are the same at all hospitals.

on the other hand much of computer labor is absolutely in a seller's market (from the point of view of the employee) and clearly does not need the same level of protection. there is a lot in many workplaces that a "computer professional" wouldn't put up with for a second.

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by revelation on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:16PM (#8138755)
That's such a beautiful poem of an idea. It all comes crashing down once it hits reality at a mere one mile per hour.

If you happen to be a tech writer, you are not exempt from overtime pay in California. Why is that, you ask? Are tech writers not minting money using a bit of time in front of a computer? Is there not a sellers market for tech writers?

But of course these are all the wrong questions to ask. It is because tech writers thought they deserved overtime pay, lobbied for it, and were granted their wishes. Scroll down for how that happened.

Scroll a bit further and you might realize that the original exemption was put in place by a long dead Republican senator from Idaho in 1990. I'm not convinced he had those deep insights into the market of computer professionals.

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by logicallee on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:39PM (#8138872)
fair enough. I was just throwing out "any logical reason (if there is one)".
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by walterbell on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:00PM (#8138641)
It is the job of any lobby to carve out exceptions to rules. From the NYT article above:

"...Under current rules, if an employer declares that an employee’s primary responsibility is executive, such as overseeing a cleanup crew, then that worker can be exempted from overtime.

White House officials said those rules were sometimes abused by employers in an attempt to avoid paying overtime. The new rules could require that employees perform a minimum percentage of “executive” work before they can be exempted from qualifying for overtime pay.

“Under current rules, it literally means that you can spend 95 percent of the time sweeping floors and stocking shelves, and if you’re responsible for supervising people 5 percent of the time, you can then be considered executive and be exempt"

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by fred_durst on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:55PM (#8139358)
That is a common tactic, but many Assistant Managers in the retail are seeing success fighting it through the courts and the push back continues to mount.

http://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2012/11/17/maxx-assistan...

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by krschultz on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:29PM (#8138498)
Nonexempt employees can still work crazy hours, they just get overtime for it.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by serge2k on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:58PM (#8138620)
That's all the more reason to demand overtime pay.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by logicallee on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:00PM (#8138640)
Yes, to demand it. My point is you can demand whatever you want. (Unlike the cleaning staff, who can "be shown the door if that's how they feel about it.")

It's not like being exempt means an employer is not allowed to offer you overtime pay. They can still do it. You can still demand it.

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by roc on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:43PM (#8138897)
> "Unlike the cleaning staff, who can "be shown the door if that's how they feel about it.""

Cleaning staff are (overwhelmingly) entitled to overtime pay, by law.

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by logicallee on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:49PM (#8138931)
yes, that is my point. they're entitled to it precisely because they're not in a position to demand it. (according to this possible logic.)
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by roc on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:15PM (#8139103)
I guess I didn't recognize your point, because I don't see a huge discrepancy in ability-to-demand overtime, between cleaning people and technology staff.

Tech workers are more-well-paid than the cleaning staff and generally better situated to negotiate for any given job. But I don't see how that necessarily carries over to increased success in negotiating payment schemes that differ from the legal and industry standard for the position.

Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by dpritchett on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:17PM (#8139493)
I think the point was that a regulator would be more sympathetically inclined to 'protect' the cleaning workers by legally mandating overtime since they necessarily have less negotiating leverage than white-collar workers.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by walterbell on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:07PM (#8139047)
In Silicon Valley, cleaning staff are hired via contractors: http://www.mercurynews.com/localnewsheadlines/ci_9331274
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by rmc on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:24PM (#8138471)
Companies would like some free labour, and to not have to pay for free overtime.
Re:LinkedIn to pay nearly $6M in unpaid overtime wages and d... by superuser2 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:18PM (#8138762)
It's intended to encourage growth by making employment cheaper.