Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ...
by harryh on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:30PM
(#8138833)
The idea that you could only use user input is not realistic. 15% of Google's incoming queries have never been seen before by the search engine. There's not enough user input available.
Re competitors, I think that's more about eyeballs than quality - Google is such a behemoth now and is entrenched with revenue from advertising - they can use their other properties and interests like mobile to feed search revenue. I really don't think they're at the top solely because they return the best results any more, because they've been without significant competition for so long.
I was actually more interested in the idea of injecting some random results (say from the top 10 pages), as that might significantly increase the relevance of their results for many queries, give them even better data from user input, and would make it very hard to game the system.