News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by sroerick on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:47AM (#8137534)
He's raising the observation that the easier it is to game Google, the less useful Google becomes.

He's not prescribing a solution. Much less the solution of Google becoming a "far-left government."

But screw equality and open access, right?

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by asuffield on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @01:58PM (#8143854)
Read the article carefully and you'll see that he does in fact prescribe a "solution": take search results away from entities who have lots of them and hand them out equally to everybody, so that everybody gets a "fair" amount of users directed to their site.

...which would of course render it utterly useless to those users and destroy any value it has as a search engine.

He even states that his main objection to Google search is that it is not acting as an artificial "leveller" to change society.

This is the manifesto of a far-left government. Google doesn't do these things because it's neither far-left nor a government, and his request is both poorly thought-out and quite bizarre.

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by rtperson on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:37PM (#8137791)
> He's not proscribing a solution.

The word you want is "prescribe." To "proscribe" means to make forbidden or illegal. https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&e...

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by sroerick on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:13PM (#8138047)
Whoops, thanks.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by Kalium on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:10PM (#8137654)
Search engines are by their very nature un-equal. There's no way around this without removing the value in having a search engine.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by sroerick on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:34PM (#8137781)
His point, and something I agree with, is that the easier gamification becomes, the less useful a search engine becomes.

I don't know if this is true for everyone. It probably isn't. (at least it isn't immediately obvious.)

But for the author it is, and I agree wholeheartedly.

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by walterbell on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:21PM (#8137711)
Some search engines, e.g. Google 7 years ago, are less un-equal than others, e.g. Google today.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by Kalium on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:25PM (#8137734)
The job of a search engine is to second-guess your desire from limited inputs and try to fulfill it. I can't think of any sane way to be "equal" about that without relying on a lot of subjective judgments. Or being bad at making decisions.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by walterbell on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:59PM (#8137941)
Is the strategic priority of Google leadership a subjective judgement? Are these subjective judgements objectively implemented? There are always winners and losers for any given ranking algorithm, the question is whether perception of neutrality has improved or declined in the last 7 years.

What is the perception of Google's neutrality in enforcement of rules against traffic arbitrage, e.g. search toolbars: http://www.benedelman.org/news/012213-1.html ?

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by Kalium on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:02PM (#8137973)
Almost anyone who loses out will perceive things as being subjectively against them. Almost anyone who wins will perceive it as being a sign of their worthiness and objective value.
Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by sroerick on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:15PM (#8138056)
Yeah, but who is making those decisions?

Google? SEO agents? Large multinational corporations?

Wikipedia is subjective too, that doesn't mean that they just give in and let PR people manage the thing.

Re:Dear Google, I am writing an open letter from the search ... by Kalium on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:36PM (#8138179)
Among other things, they pay attention to whether or not the user comes back to look at results again. So in a significant way, it's the market.