News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by mullingitover on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:02PM (#8135319)
I mean no disrespect to the soldiery, but why use soldiers for this, and not the DIA/NSA/CIA/various other TLAs? I guess that's what I'm confused about. Grunts wearing camouflage sitting in front of a laptop trying to outbrain someone seems humorously perverse. It's like some high-level bureaucrat has it in his mind that 'cyberattack' necessarily means that the military has to do it, because we obviously use the military for attacking things.
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by doug11235 on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:19PM (#8135348)
You probably don't realize how much crossover there is between the military and intel. For example, the CSS in NSA/CSS - http://www.nsa.gov/about/central_security_service/
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by phaus on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:08AM (#8135465)
>I mean no disrespect to the soldiery, but why use soldiers for this, and not the DIA/NSA/CIA/various other TLAs?

I specifically said that I wasn't advocating this as a military mission. I was just stating that if it was a military mission, the Soldiers themselves wouldn't be the reason that it fails.

>Grunts wearing camouflage sitting in front of a laptop trying to outbrain someone seems humorously perverse.

A grunt is an infantryman. Not all Soldiers are grunts. The Soldiers that work as security analysts do it as a full time job. They still have to take a couple PT tests each year and qualify once or twice a year with an M16, but they spend most of their time doing their job.

I'm not sure how wearing camofluage affects a person's ability to use a computer? They are people like everyone else.

Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by socceroos on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:59AM (#8135859)
I guarantee you will not attract the best talent if your vision includes them wearing camouflage.
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by lsc on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:26AM (#8136014)
There are lots of downsides to the military as an employer. The dresscode is pretty far down that list.

The biggest downside, I think? As a civilian, it is my right to walk off a job at any time. Sure, there are expectations that I'll give you some notice (and I will) but worst comes to worst? I can always walk, and the worst my employer can do is call me bad names.

In the military, those contracts? they mean something. Yeah, you can ask to be transferred around; hell, I know someone who was able to actually quit the navy half way through basic, but it was a big fucking deal.

I mean, there are advantages to the military, too. I'm not saying it's a bad choice for everyone. I'm just saying that wearing dorky pants doesn't even make the list.

The military, like most government jobs, makes a lot of sense for someone who values stability. There are plenty of skilled people that value stability over the ability to leave; I'm just not one of them.

Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by phaus on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:29PM (#8137754)
Not every talented person thinks the exact same way that you do. Its a fact that the way the military operates automatically excludes a large part of the talent pool that simply doesn't want to deal with all the bullshit, but everyone has their own set of priorities.
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by walshemj on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:41AM (#8136806)
Nah won't want to be seen dead in standard kit they end to go for northface, Barbour, camper or merrell for boots just the SAD and SAS do.
Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by s_q_b on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:35AM (#8137457)
US Cyber Command, the main elite military cyberwarfare unit, is under the joint leadership of the NSA director. What they're doing now is moving the techniques "down-market" so that ordinary units have cyber capabilities as well. Think JSOC vs. regular infantry. You need both to be effective.

Amusing side note, the MD5 hash of CYBERCOM's mission statement, "9ec4c12949a4f31474f299058ce2b22a", is to my knowledge the only hash emblazoned on an agency seal.

Re:In secret cyberwar game, reservist techies pummel miltary... by wisty on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @08:47AM (#8136600)
The same reason the Army has mechanics to fix their tanks, not some "US Tank Repair Agency".

Also, if you were an officer, how willing would you be to trust a hacker from another agency, if you didn't have someone you trusted to vet their advice?

There'd also be concerns about red tape. If a low ranking officer isn't sure about something, can they put in a tech support ticket to a three letter agency?