Yap. Dealing with the military as a customer I have definitely have seen red tape that goes beyond reasonable for security and actually downright counter-productive (the steps needed to jump through to "secure" a box, many are wasteful, antiquated, yet some obvious ones are not mentioned.
There are things like "tcpdump must not be installed". So debugging is a pain, so then fine, I'll just use a python wrapper around libpcap then.
Some of the password policies are odd, don't remember exactly but requiring large passwords made of random gibberish instead of long pass phrases just make people write them posted notes and carrying them in their wallets.
Must be nice, last government SOC I worked in, we could only script with powershell 1.0 installed. Sadly, that was just a year ago.
We had tcpdump and Wireshark, but we weren't allowed to capture anything with it.
So how does anybody know there isn't data exfiltration going on?
'So... if they don't intercept network traffic, they were trustworthy and it wouldn't matter. But if they are not trustworthy... they can still sniff the traffic? Are you sure it's fine?'
'Yeah, every modern network is switched so there is nothing to sniff'
These are all problems that are slowly working their way up the policy chains. E.g. RAND has put out a very good study on all this, http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR430.html that discusses the challenges with public sector/military hiring (and retention).
It may yet have to come down to putting the effort heavily on the Reserves though, because for all the other things the military can change, I don't see culture as being one of them. Even the legendarily free-wheeling communities like submarines and fighter aviation deal with red tape and subsuming egos to the team.
It doesn't matter that the problems are working their way up the policy chains if they are only going to die when they get to the top. You yourself admitted that they are unlikely to change the culture, and we both know they aren't about to pay a competitive wage to the military. Unfortunately, that leaves us with things exactly the way they are now.
The military likes to talk about starting to take various issues seriously, yet it is an exceptionally rare occasion when they actually do.
The most "conservative" company would have techies that don't meet any customers come in a suit, and those are almost extinct now.
In a military, depending on where you are and your rank, you could detention / penalties for not being shaved, not having your shoes shined, having a haircut that's too long by a few centimeters. You often can't take a week (or even a day) off without weeks notice unless it's an emergency. You could go to jail for disobeying a higher up.
And most importantly, if you signed up for (say) 3 years, you can't quit before those three years are up. Seriously, if you think corporate red tape is anything remotely like serving in the military - you need to revisit your idea of what the military is.
So if your .com boss decides to fire you for being a dirty hippie, you pretty much get walked out and that's it. More likely they would make up a bunch of B.S. to "prove" your inadequacy so they don't have to pay severance or unemployment claims.
In .mil its surprisingly similar but much more formal. UCMJ article 15 punishments, some written formal counseling, courtmartial trial, yes you can get downsized in the .mil by reorgs making your slot coincidentally happen to disappear, its all very complicated and ritualistic but basically does the same thing as .com.
You only go to jail in .mil if you more or less want to. There are always alternatives that are generally easier than "just say no". Its vaguely similar to .com life in that telling your boss "no" is much more likely to get you fired than explaining "yes, but ...". Along with the traditional homer simpson move of just go to work and retire in place or monkey wrench stuff.
One difference is transferring is much easier and much more uniform in .mil if you have a bad boss than in .com where that may range from no-problemo to impossible without a career death penalty being assessed but usually on average much harder in .com world.
And re:transferring - that's another thing that's different in the army; The army can transfer you to, say, Iraq, with a couple of days notice, without giving you the ability to refuse. Ever had anything like that happen in your .com days?
If I were to join the military right now wanting to work on computer systems, how long would it take before I'm actually preforming that role, or would they have to "break" me first? Hackers have no desire to do that when they can easily stay in the private sector and earn twice the pay and have a nice cushy office to work out of.
There should be some kind of alternate route to joining the military for officer and specialization roles (in my opinion of course, I am certainly interested to here if anyone has objections). Give me a few tests, an interview, a basic physical, a polygraph, and some IT training to get familiar with the systems and let me go to work. High pay isn't really an issue for me personally as long as I enjoy the work and am constantly learning or teaching.
Having access to that information is a huge responsibility. There have been spies at all ranks that have done large amounts of harm to the US military. It is absolutely necessary to lock down machines and have strict security checks over each other a logging of everything.
The exception is if you have a specialized degree there is officers school for the branches, but basic training is still required, you will still be marching and be broken in, but after that will be more classrooms than physical activities.
Pilots especially must be physically fit. I've heard that leg strength is especially important so that you don't pass out at high g-forces. Drone pilots probably not so much, obviously.
The Reserve forces might be slightly less rigorous, but I'm not positive.
The cyber warfare stuff is mostly Army and Navy though as far as I know.
Agencies like the DHS are the ones that are really struggling to find IT talent. They have a huge amount of responsibility (security all non-military government infrastructure) and have a bad reputation currently (because of airport security staff).
[1] http://static.e-publishing.af.mil/production/1/saf_cio_a6/pu...
Infantrymen won't have marketable skills, but we are talking about military security analysts. These guys often do have skills equivalent to their civilian counterparts. You seem to be making the same assumption that many others in this thread have: that all Soldiers are infantrymen of less than average intelligence.
My surprise had more to do with learning that cyberwarefare reservists exist, let alone enlisted soldiers. (I'm not familiar with the military.)
[1]: http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/R... p.64
I can see how you would be surprised. It seems counter-intuitive, but its actually normal for reservists in technical fields to be better at their jobs than the military. The best example I can think of is the field of aviation. Many reserve pilots are commercial pilots that get to fly 1000s of hours each year. Their full-time military counterparts don't get to fly their fancy fighter jets very often, because its really expensive.
Doctors are officers. This means that they get paid much more than Soldiers, but its still a laughably low amount when you compare it to a civilian doctor's salary.
Pilots are also officers. Their salaries are closer to the civilian world, but they are still probably a little low.
I don't think the Army is about to convert tens of thousands of IT specialists and Intel analysts from enlisted Soldiers to commissioned officers. Even if they did, the majority of them would still be making well below market rate.
Even the officer ranks that pay competitively require 10-20 years of service. At that point you are going to have a salary that's comparable to a civilian security analyst with a couple years' experience.
I think flexibility is the real problem with military hiring, not absolute pay levels.
Its also not a technical job in the traditional sense, 70Ds typically spend 8 years as a 70B (Even though a lot of them will be slotted as 70Ds much earlier than this) which is essentially a management position at a medical facility.
From the description of 70D, it could end up being a technical job depending on the particular assignment, but its more oriented towards healthcare management types.
Its not a bad deal at all if you are looking for a way to pay off your student loans.
The allowances in the Army are for things like jumping out of a plane, scuba diving, foreign languages, combat pay, etc.
The Army still has this attitude that if you aren't outside all day, running around yelling at people, then you must not be doing any work. I'm not sure if that will ever change.
Officer income is higher than Enlisted income, but it still starts at around 34k for a single person. Depending on where you live, its probably going to be about 46k for someone that's married. That's still pretty low for the type of people they are looking for.
My comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8009579 applies again. The 'cyberwar' does not matter, or at least not in a way that threatens the existing power structure. To the extent that there are duelling hackers out there, they're operating in the financial realm, which is very far from the military and extremely resistant to being told what to do.
Besides, conventional war is over between major powers. There's colonial policing, guerilla warfare, secret ops -- and then straight up to nuclear exchanges. NATO's eastern border is Poland; Russia's western border is some way east of Donetsk; in the middle is an ugly unacknowledged skirmish using Ukraine as a buffer zone. The skirmish will continue unescalated because neither side can afford to stop the gas pipelines flowing through Ukraine.
(The Russian missile launcher was tracked by, among other things, geotagged selfies on Instagram posted by one of the operators. Does that count as "cyberwar"?)
Result: "Forget it, let's just hire some contractors."
This isn't entirely true. Unlike the military pay scale, the GS pay scale does have ways to pay certain fields more money. Its not very much in most cases, but its there. IT jobs generally get you 10% more than other fields.
The only GS jobs I know of that get a substantial about of extra money are the Scientific and Medical jobs. There are special codes that allow them to add at least another 50k-100k to their income, depending on the specific type of position that they hold.
And hiring contractors from Booze ma kidney - has worked out so well for them hasn't it.
Federal recruiting can be quite a minefield, which is a significant problem in fast-moving professions. According to this article the NSA don't opt out of the GS scale, but that's not to say they don't offer temporary positions with slightly different criteria: http://work.chron.com/nsa-pay-scale-16399.html
I'm unsure if it's different on the military side but typically that pay / Basic allowance for housing / etc is also clearly defined in advance.
The biggest difference, is that their promotion structure is split into two parts: there is a technical route to promotion and an administrative route. This means that you can either be good at being in charge of people and get promoted (administrative), or just be good at what you do (technical). It leads to interesting situations where a GS12 is put in charge of divisions comprising GS15 veterans of 20 years experience, but all in all it is by far the best government run organization I've worked for.
The UK scientific civil service has similar problems in that for generic management roles they are paid fairly well for high end technical skills not so much.
Even worse once you get into roles for the TLA's - it will end up like the 30's where the only people that the security services could recruit where those with private incomes or ex military on pensions.
>Do the military "cyberwarriors" even have local admin rights on their machines?
We don't, hell I don't even have access to some of the basic tools I need (i.e. version control)
>Hackers don't sign up for active duty military.
They do, I've met the smartest people I know in the military . The hacker types never stay though they either get kicked out because they don't want to put up with the bullshit or separate after their first enlistment and quadruple their salary.
Basically the problem with the military is that they won't (or can't) pay enough to retain any of the talent they have and are unwilling to compensate for the low salary by changing the "culture" they've developed over the last century.