Not at all. Maybe though, he's a local middle-man in a business which is going toward global middle men.
After all, Uber and Lyft are nothing if not middle men.
- They don't know each other (lack of contact method)
- They don't know how much they charge.
- They don't know if they are trustworthy.
- They don't know if they will maliciously overcharge or if they won't honor the contract.
The completely exact middleman work that Uber does between drivers and passengers.
In NY, the Chinese and the Korean community have their own network knowing how to reach the Chinese/Korean-speaking car service and shuttle service. Uber or alike cannot beat this system. These locale-specific service operate with just telephone. Very school but effective! No app, no Internet access. Pretty reliable and cheap.
So all he need to do is to find a community to target at and find drivers willing to join him.
It's basically a community lock-in. So a Uber-like clone will have to break this "monopoly practice" not by just translating the app, but actually knows how the community works.
Considering you can put your destination address in the app, it should be a huge improvement to anyone who doesn't know the language (or with disabilities).
I don't really see how it applies in this situation. (e.g. you can use uber today and a taxi tomorrow and suffer no loss of value).
Eventually, you get a network of users/drivers - each new driver is available to many customers, and each customer will make themselves available to many drivers.
It's not a perfect N(N-1)/2 mesh, but then neither were fax machines (not everyone wanted to fax everyone else) - but the same concept of network value exists.
We have no idea what the future hold, and remember Uber is the new kid on the block here.
I appreciate his spirit, but I don't think he's fully estimating what it would involve to beat Uber at its game. He'll have to hire more drivers, have lower prices and still be up against a huge network effect wall. He seems jazzed with Flywheel, but they could stop sending him business tomorrow.
One of my favorite parts about Uber is that it's in so many cities and has consistency (easy to see pricing, if there's a problem I know who to contact, etc). I'm never going to seek out DeSoto Cab Co on purpose.
Basically, if the rules tilt towards the Uber model there is no reason for Kim to exist. He's a middle man in a business that is going the opposite direction.