News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday August 04, 2014 @06:59PM (#8134539)
It should be grounds for classification as a vexatious litigant since it clearly indicates that they're not serious about following through with a lawsuit and are just running a shakedown operation.
Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by pdabbadabba on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:59PM (#8134983)
I don't see why. Lawsuits are expensive, and as a plaintiff, you know you aren't guaranteed to win. So if you discover that your expected recovery (p of victory * the lesser of the expected damages or defendants' assets) is less than the cost of maintaining the suit, why wouldn't you drop it?

Think about the consequences of automatically categorizing such plaintiffs as "vexatious litigants." You would have a bunch of plaintiffs in court who didn't want to be there, wasting their own time, the defendant's time, and the court's time. It seems to me that nobody would benefit from that rule except lawyers. Though if the lawyer is charging a contingent fee, they don't win either. (Of course there is a separate question of how far into the case should a plaintiff be able to drop the suit without forfeiting his right to bring it again later, but there is already a set of pretty fair and commonsense rules about this in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and state procedural rules. http://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_41)

Sure, in this case Personal Audio's attempts to drop the suit might (or might not) be just another symptom of their general sleaziness, but this sort of maneuver is very common in all litigation, both legitimate and sleazy.

Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by baddox on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:55PM (#8135151)
I agree. I think the patent system is bonkers, and these trolls are awful, but in general it seems pretty reasonable to only sue a party for damages when that party can feasibly pay the damages.
Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by gertef on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:50PM (#8134743)
If you smash my car and I sue you for $10,000 damages, and then I drop the case when I discover that you have no assets, is that vexatious litigation?
Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by scott_karana on Monday August 04, 2014 @08:39PM (#8134906)
If you claim that 20 different people collectively smashed your car window, charge them individually for full damages, and then only decide to charge the ones who have money, is it vexatious?
Re:Adam Carolla won’t let Personal Audio drop podcast patent... by judk on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:33PM (#8135376)
That sounds like "joint and several liability", a standard legal model.