Right now the typical discount falls between 50% and 90% depending on the treatment and agreements made. If "Obamacare" had capped insurance discounting to something like 35-40% (which is still perfectly reasonable) we would have seen uninsured patient's costs drop between 10% and 60%.
As it stands Hospitals and drug companies know that insurance will negotiate a discount so they just increase the cost to compensate. Instead of something costing 3K with a 0% discount, it is 4.8K with a 60% "discount." If discounting were scrapped altogether it would be a huge "win" for almost everyone (e.g. reduced management overhead at hospitals, uninsured patients, et al).
The only party who wins by the current discounting culture is the insurance companies as it acts as a giant "lock in." Even if you're wealthy and can afford your own treatment insurance still makes sense as you'll get a huge discount not otherwise available.
If they needed to charge everyone on the order of $1000/pill to recoup expenses, that would be one thing. That's not the issue, since they are offering it to most people (who do have insurance) at dramatically lower prices.
I know HNers are in love with market segmentation, but isn't there an ethical problem with using price to segment a market for treatment for serious medical problems based on who has insurance and who doesn't?
It's been a while since the first thread on this, but I'll just quote from the sovaldi website:
We believe that cost should not be a barrier to receiving treatment. That’s why the makers of SOVALDI offer a co-pay coupon. If you are eligible, you may pay no more than $5 per co-pay.
The SOVALDI co-pay coupon program will cover the out-of-pocket costs of your SOVALDI prescriptions after you pay the first $5 per prescription fill, up to a maximum of 20% of the catalog price of a 12-week regimen of SOVALDI. The coupon can be applied to up to 6 fills
So, if your health insurance pharmacy coverage were 80/20, instead of paying your end (20%) out of pocket, you'd pay $5 per fill. So you're paying very close to $0 per pill, instead of $1000. Well, ignoring your deductable, which might be significant, but the obamacare max is $6350, so that's an order of magnitude cost decrease for the Sovaldi prescription even if you have no other out of pocket healthcare costs that year.
The only remaining, meaningful question is: how much are insurance companies paying Gilead per pill?