News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Contrarian View of MITx: What Are We Doing? by samsolomon on Sunday August 03, 2014 @04:39PM (#8129112)
The problem with most MOOCs is that they've taken the part of school that sucks—lectures and homework—and put it online. Inspiration and community are the best parts of school, and they are nowhere to be found.
Re:A Contrarian View of MITx: What Are We Doing? by freyr on Sunday August 03, 2014 @05:48PM (#8129291)
> Inspiration and community are the best parts of school, and they are nowhere to be found.

Yes. Other things not found:

* Program structure

* Incentive for passing your courses (i.e. getting kicked out of school)

* Brand recognition associated with a diploma, to help you land a good job

* Keg parties

* Networking with classmates, alumni, and, if you're lucky, professors, to help you land a good job

For these reasons, and others, MOOCs in their current form don't pose an immediate threat to colleges.

Still, I think technology could be leveraged to make traditional programs more efficient.

For instance, university professors serve two functions: they spend most of their time and effort doing research, then they also have to deliver calculus/biology/whatever lectures to undergrads. In practice, the overlap between great researchers and great lecturers is often small. Why not supplement undergraduate education using canonical lectures from the very best speakers? I imagine some students are already doing this, by watching Khan Academy or pulling the lectures from MOOCs that feature better speakers than their professors.

Also, as tablet/e-reader screens continue to improve, digital textbooks will likely become more prevalent. There is so much room for improvement of digital textbooks by abandoning the one-to-one mapping from paper textbooks; specifically, by using multimedia more effectively and providing interactive examples. Further, adaptive or interactive problem sets would provide a rich set of data to identify where students get lost. A/B testing could identify which presentations are most effective. There's a lot to be done here.

Re:A Contrarian View of MITx: What Are We Doing? by XorNot on Sunday August 03, 2014 @09:14PM (#8129799)
Getting kicked out of school is something we need to replicate? Heck no.

You either have the motovation to learn or you don't, but the point of online learning is to let people figure that out themselves. We absolutely do not need some ridiculous system of gating access when we won't need it.

Re:A Contrarian View of MITx: What Are We Doing? by vecter on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:15PM (#8129361)
I agree that a huge value of a school is learning from your peers, but I personally think homework is one of the most important parts of school also. That's honestly where I learned most of what I did in college.
Re:A Contrarian View of MITx: What Are We Doing? by ghaff on Sunday August 03, 2014 @07:21PM (#8129513)
I agree at least up to a point depending on the course. And, having said that, it's a problem for most MOOCs:

The fact that student are mostly casual and at least shouldn't expect any sort of meaningful certification means that it's hard to expect the sort of time commitment that I put into many of my university courses.

There aren't good mechanisms to evaluate and provide quality feedback for in-depth homework. (And peer review most certainly doesn't count.)