News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by chatmasta on Sunday August 03, 2014 @10:11PM (#8129953)
About a month ago, a study came to the same conclusion about modern Americans. That is, Americans born in rural areas who move to urban centers have higher cognitive ability on average than their counterparts who stay put.

Overview Article: http://www.citylab.com/work/2014/07/the-smartest-people-move...

Paper (paid gateway, can't find free): http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289614...

Anecdotally, from my own experience this isn't surprising at all. I grew up in a small town, and wanted to move to a big city since I was about ten years old. I just got bored in that small town. Seeing the same < 100 people every day, going to the same places... It's simply not as stimulating. When I went to boarding school, I found that many of my peers from similar backgrounds felt the same. Eight years later, almost all of us are living in a big city. Maybe this will change as we begin to have families, but it does seem that we all had an instinctive desire toward the draw of big cities.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Houshalter on Monday August 04, 2014 @01:44AM (#8130513)
It seems more likely that they have to leave to go to college, or that they are more likely to take occupations that require them to move.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by burkemw3 on Sunday August 03, 2014 @04:27PM (#8129073)
For a moment after reading "a study of 150,000 historical figures that shows cities have long acted as cultural magnets" I was wondering if 'historical figures' referred to people or the actual data. In this case, it's both!
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by micro_cam on Sunday August 03, 2014 @09:00PM (#8129747)
The headline (not the hn title which is the subtitle of the article) is really over the top.

The conclusion that "the brainy" have moved to cities at any different rate then the general populous is in no way supported by the source paper. In fact it states explicitly that historical figures are just the only people we have good data for and implies they represent patterns in the population as a whole.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by throwaway1982 on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:21PM (#8129377)
Of interest to me is if this trend will or even is still continuing now that we don't rely on the slow communication and transportation methods of the past. I'm currently working for a company slightly past "startup stage" with a bunch of smart people in as rural a location as you can get in the North East and we constantly fly out and teleconference with big partners and clients in San Francisco without much or any net price/hassle if you factor in all the cost/time/stress savings of our location.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Swizec on Sunday August 03, 2014 @07:17PM (#8129501)
I'm no historical figure, but I can't feel productive in a location where I can't just randomly decide one night that I've had it with work, want to throw my laptop out hte window, and should just go out for a pint. So you get up, walk outside, and voila, full bars on any random night of the week.

Sometimes you run into people from your field, sometimes from other fields, sometimes nobody at all. But it's a good way to recharge your brain, increase productivity, and merge disparate ideas.

Your mileage may vary, but I really really need that.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Amezarak on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:50AM (#8132289)
> I'm no historical figure, but I can't feel productive in a location where I can't just randomly decide one night that I've had it with work, want to throw my laptop out hte window, and should just go out for a pint. So you get up, walk outside, and voila, full bars on any random night of the week.

That doesn't seem to be a really high bar. For example, the county I live in has approximately 140k people and a population density of 128 / square mile. I think that most people would regard it as pretty rural, and it is in flyover country.

Yet I can still go out any day of the week to any one of a sizable number of bars and expect them to be decently full. I've run into all kinds of interesting people...though I don't expect to ever run into anybody famous.

I've traveled a lot and I don't mind big cities, but I've never really understood what they have to offer that I don't already have, barring certain kinds of professional network effects (e.g. Silicon Valley for startups, LA for the movie industry.)

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Swizec on Monday August 04, 2014 @01:13PM (#8132827)
> Yet I can still go out any day of the week to any one of a sizable number of bars and expect them to be decently full. I've run into all kinds of interesting people...though I don't expect to ever run into anybody famous.

In my experience there is a big difference between "sizable number of bars ... decently full" and "a lot of bars/clubs/places ... full".

In my home town (300k people) you get many of bars that are pretty full a lot of the time, some bars that are full-ish some of the time, and a lot of bars that are mostly empty most of the time. And nightclubs, god help you if your taste in music is not mainstream. You will go to a club on a super duper full night and there will be 20 people there.

Compare that to SF. More bars than I could visit in my lifetime. Most of them decently full most of the time. Most of them packed on party nights. No matter what music I decide to listen to, the club will be packed. As obscure as I can bear, club will still be packed.

And SF is not even a giant city. It's got less than 3x the population of my home town.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by XaspR8d on Sunday August 03, 2014 @09:43PM (#8129876)
I appreciate the way you worded it, and I agree 100% for myself. I'm hardly a strong extrovert, but something about the assurance of being able to go and find activity at any time really makes me less stressed and more effective at working.

But I accept that this may not be a helpful environment for everyone. I know I have to balance this need with the needs of my SO, who feels similarly about having forests and lakes nearby (which certainly soothe me, but don't rank as high as having humans about).

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Swizec on Sunday August 03, 2014 @11:26PM (#8130168)
Solution: Move to a small city in Europe.

Back home[1] I live in downtown area so there's plenty of people at all times, but at the same time you can see the Alps from almost anywhere in the city on most days. And they're just an hour's drive away.

I imagine a lot of the smaller cities in Europe fulfill these criteria.

[1] Ljubljana - population about 300k, during workdays swells up to about 500k people. Small, but still lively.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by ams6110 on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:51PM (#8129451)
I think it will continue. There are still significant economic efficiencies in high population densities. Remote video conferences only address a very small slice of those.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by bergie on Monday August 04, 2014 @05:19AM (#8130917)
Yep. Moving a place like San Francisco or Berlin might not be required for the "actual work", but it certainly provides other benefits in available services, cultural activities, etc.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by mgraczyk on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:22PM (#8129378)
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by pigeons on Sunday August 03, 2014 @05:22PM (#8129216)
really a lot of pro-city living propoganda on HN. I've just accepted its not the mountainsteader demographic.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by corford on Sunday August 03, 2014 @08:27PM (#8129671)
Until quite recently I lived at the foot of this: http://www.valcanigou.net/IMG/jpg/canigou01.jpg
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by micro_cam on Sunday August 03, 2014 @09:04PM (#8129762)
Haven't heard that term before but I live in a farm house at the base of a wilderness range in the northern rockies if that counts.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by contingencies on Sunday August 03, 2014 @07:30PM (#8129530)
FWIW, I live on a mountain in southwest China.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by Lambdanaut on Sunday August 03, 2014 @09:54PM (#8129905)
Is it that brainy people moved to cities, or that cities made people brainy?
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by slurry on Sunday August 03, 2014 @04:02PM (#8128973)
Thus, NIMBYs and city haters are standing in the way of history.

Lobbying for height restrictions? Lobbying against the next Michelangelo.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by seszett on Sunday August 03, 2014 @04:46PM (#8129129)
Paris has height restrictions, which doesn't seem to have deterred artists.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by slurry on Sunday August 03, 2014 @04:53PM (#8129150)
Paris has height restrictions, which doesn't seem to have deterred artists.

On the contrary, http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/2/a096d1d0-d2ec-11e2-aac2-00144...

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by oska on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:08PM (#8129337)
Your linked article does not support the case that height restrictions are what is making Paris, or other global capitals, expensive.

But thanks for the link, I found it an interesting read.

Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by nitrogen on Sunday August 03, 2014 @11:47PM (#8130224)
Other articles on HN have supported the idea that height restrictions contribute to scarcity, and that scarcity contributes to high prices. The supply is not allowed to increase to meet demand.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by twic on Sunday August 03, 2014 @06:47PM (#8129438)
Maybe that's what attracted Napoleon.
Re:Historical figures have moved to cities in the same way f... by nhebb on Sunday August 03, 2014 @07:29PM (#8129529)