Re:University of Wisconsin to reprise controversial monkey s...
by nmrm on Sunday August 03, 2014 @05:55AM
(#8127541)
Another committee of scientists -- another IRB board -- probably would have not allowed the study.
Therefore, the parent's appeal to the IRB process as the harbinger of ethics is misguided.
If any IRB would deem a study ethical, then there's probably consensus among the scientific community on the cost-benefit tradeoff of the study. If one IRB deemed the study ethical, and if there're probably a lot of other potential IRBs that would not, then appealing to some sort of scientific consensus on the matter is a misnomer.
Therefore, the parent's appeal to the IRB process as the harbinger of ethics is misguided.
If any IRB would deem a study ethical, then there's probably consensus among the scientific community on the cost-benefit tradeoff of the study. If one IRB deemed the study ethical, and if there're probably a lot of other potential IRBs that would not, then appealing to some sort of scientific consensus on the matter is a misnomer.