News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by pessimizer on Saturday August 02, 2014 @04:27PM (#8125925)
I am pro-net neutrality, and I think that particular packets getting QoS guarantees is exactly what I'm against - and pretty much completely describes what I'm against.

I don't know what net neutrality with QoS guarantees even means. Unless QoS is a promise that the ISPs will be making to me, guaranteeing that I will always have a particular amount of bandwidth - but I don't want any of the packets that I am sending or receiving to get favorable treatment of any other packets that I'm sending or receiving.

I'd even like to see law about the variables that upstream caching algorithms can use, and I think that situations like the Netflix appliance could absolutely legitimately be declared a no-no. Packet throughput should be fungible, and it is before people start slipping each other cash.

Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by nitrogen on Saturday August 02, 2014 @04:47PM (#8125986)
QoS is a highly desirable feature of a network, iff you, the end user, control the QoS selection. If I'm playing a fast-paced online game, talking to a group of friends with VoIP, and downloading a movie from one of the online stores to watch later, I'd like to place the priority of the movie's packets below the game and voice packets. But if the ISP does that for me, gives me no choice in the matter, and/or prioritizes my minimum guaranteed allotment movie packets above or below the voice packets of other customers, that's not okay.

I've mentioned this strategy a few times before on HN, starting ~4 years ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2049784

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4860164

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4860180

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7711264

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7911677

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8058319

Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by GauntletWizard on Sunday August 03, 2014 @02:51AM (#8127287)
Yes; QOS has no place crossing the boundaries of a network segment - It should allow me to control the ingress and egress of my network, but be stripped before it gets to a network "trunk" like an ISP.

Further on that; If bandwidth on a segment is constrained, the ISP should divide it as fairly as possible, while also trying to maximize throughput. Each user should get an equal share, and if they're using less than that, the remainder should be apportioned to the other users evenly.

Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by nitrogen on Sunday August 03, 2014 @02:57AM (#8127295)
It seems to me that some level of either user-controlled QoS or congestion notification is desirable at the ISP level, since your software (e.g. Netflix, VoIP) might not know that the ISP network is congested, but you'd still prefer to tell your ISP's routers to prioritize the VoIP over the Netflix (within your allotted share of bandwidth, of course).
Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by pessimizer on Sunday August 03, 2014 @08:06AM (#8127718)
>QoS is a highly desirable feature of a network, iff you, the end user, control the QoS selection.

Agreed, although I think of that as something that I do at my own router, but that only covers my outbound. Being able to control what comes down to me would only be an improvement.

Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by A_COMPUTER on Saturday August 02, 2014 @07:35PM (#8126431)
I guess I disagree then, because when I think of QoS, I think of what has to be done to keep a network and services on it working smoothly. I consider it a violation of net neutrality when a packet is blocked or throttled for political or business reasons, but not when a packet is blocked or throttled to keep the integrity and functionality of the network intact. Where this still intersects with politics is when an ISP makes claims like that what its customers use the network for is itself causing problems, which really is a business problem--if all your customers are using Netflix and it's choking your network, that's not a technical problem per se--it's a mismatch between the features your network offers and the features your network users desire to use. Which is a business problem. So I am against the usage of QoS as a FUD tactic, that is to say, "we have to throttle your traffic because you're abusing the network by using it."

I don't consider technical QoS decisions to be a violation of net neutrality, because everything that is permitted is not good. I can saturate my upload with bittorrent traffic so that it makes looking at websites unusable. Dropping my bittorrent upload just enough that it doesn't cause this problem doesn't violate my rights as far as I'm concerned.

Re:Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Interne... by pessimizer on Sunday August 03, 2014 @08:19AM (#8127740)
>Dropping my bittorrent upload just enough that it doesn't cause this problem doesn't violate my rights as far as I'm concerned.

When I do it, yes. Not when someone else is doing it to me.