Re:Most Math Problems Do Not Have a Unique Right Answer
by jameshart on Saturday August 02, 2014 @12:48PM
(#8125256)
Right - mathematical insight is what tells you which factors to measure in order to make a prediction, and which factors to ignore. A great example I've seen recently was in the context of the solar road concept, where there was a discussion around how much pressure is exerted by a vehicle on the road surface, in the context of determining if solar panels could realistically be manufactured to stand that pressure. Someone argued that the pressure would be roughly equal to the tire pressure of the vehicles passing over; eminently sensible people then tried to make mathematical arguments that that was nonsense, because the weight of a vehicle had to have some bearing on it - it stands to reason trucks must exert more pressure than cars or bikes, right? So the assumption is that the formula for road pressure must depend in some way on the vehicle weight.
Well, yes it does - but so does the tire pressure. If you add weight to a car, the tire pressure increases. So does the pressure it exerts on the road. Noticing that vehicle weight is a common scaling factor in two places tells you there's probably a simple relationship between the tire pressure and the road pressure. And it leads you to the counterintuitive conclusion that yes, if you increase the pressure in a tire, and keep vehicle weight constant, it increases the pressure the tire exerts on the road. Pressure's tricky and counterintuitive like that.
For sure, the road pressure and tire pressure aren't necessarily equal - not all of the weight of a vehicle is borne by the column of air between the contact patch and the wheel hub, some is transferred through the sidewalls, some through the tire rim to the air above the hub, and so on, and if you are a tire manufacturer or a formula one race engineer you will want to take those things into account. But for arguing about what the pressure on the surface of the solar panels in a road surface would be, tire pressures are -a- right answer.
Well, yes it does - but so does the tire pressure. If you add weight to a car, the tire pressure increases. So does the pressure it exerts on the road. Noticing that vehicle weight is a common scaling factor in two places tells you there's probably a simple relationship between the tire pressure and the road pressure. And it leads you to the counterintuitive conclusion that yes, if you increase the pressure in a tire, and keep vehicle weight constant, it increases the pressure the tire exerts on the road. Pressure's tricky and counterintuitive like that.
For sure, the road pressure and tire pressure aren't necessarily equal - not all of the weight of a vehicle is borne by the column of air between the contact patch and the wheel hub, some is transferred through the sidewalls, some through the tire rim to the air above the hub, and so on, and if you are a tire manufacturer or a formula one race engineer you will want to take those things into account. But for arguing about what the pressure on the surface of the solar panels in a road surface would be, tire pressures are -a- right answer.